Hey folks, I've been rolling out Rapid7 InsightCloudSec across our AWS environments and hit a snag. We have a bunch of "test" or "scratch" S3 buckets that various teams spin up for short-term work. These get flagged constantly for lacking encryption or public access blocks, which is expected, but it creates a ton of noise in our compliance dashboards.
I want to exclude entire *resource types* (specifically these non-production S3 buckets) from being scanned, rather than tagging each one individually or writing complex rules post-scan. The goal is to keep the signal-to-noise ratio high for our actual production assets.
From digging through the docs, I see you can create policies and filters, but most examples focus on excluding by tag or region. Has anyone set up a broad exclusion based on a naming pattern or a custom label for a resource type? For instance, something like:
```yaml
# Hypothetical filter idea
exclusion_filter:
resource_type: aws_s3_bucket
name_pattern: "*-test-*"
condition: OR
tags:
- environment: sandbox
```
Is this best handled through the UI's Asset Groups, or via the API when defining scan scope? Any gotchas with permissions or historical data when you add an exclusion?
Also curious if this approach impacts the overall security score calculation, or if excluded resources are just hidden from the view.
--builder
Latency is the enemy, but consistency is the goal.
Yeah, that's a common pain point. The Asset Groups feature is what you're looking for, not the policy filters. You can define an asset group with a rule that specifically excludes resources based on a tag key-value pair (like `environment = sandbox`) or a name pattern. When you set up your scan scope, you point it at that asset group. The gotcha is that any resource matching the exclusion rule won't be inventoried at all, so you lose historical tracking for those buckets.
For your naming pattern idea, you'd build a rule in the asset group like this (using the UI's query builder, but the API uses similar logic):
```
resource.type = 'aws.s3.bucket' AND resource.name MATCHES '.*-test-.*'
```
Then set that group as an *exclusion* group for your scans. The main catch is permissions; the service account Rapid7 uses needs the same broad read permissions to *discover* these resources first, in order to exclude them. It can't exclude what it can't see.
Automate everything. Twice.
Asset Groups are indeed the path, but there's a subtlety in how you configure them that tripped us up. You don't just build the group with the exclusion logic; you have to explicitly set the group's *type* to "Exclusion" in the UI (or via the API `type` field) when you create it. A regular asset group used for scoping won't work as a filter.
Also, on the permissions catch the other poster mentioned: if your scan role doesn't have read permissions on the excluded resources at all, the scanner will throw errors. You still need list/get permissions on the S3 service, even for the buckets you intend to ignore. The exclusion happens in the application logic, not at the API call level.
Connecting the dots.
The "set the group's type to Exclusion" part is crucial and not obvious in the docs. I missed that when I first tried it.
But if you use a name pattern, won't you still catch every new bucket that matches? That seems like maintenance via naming convention, which our teams are bad at. Does tagging each one really take longer than chasing down misnamed buckets later?
That's a good point about naming conventions. But isn't the real issue that teams might avoid tagging these test buckets altogether, even if it's policy? A name pattern will at least catch some of them.
Maybe a hybrid approach could work? Use a broad name pattern like "*-temp" or "*-scratch" for exclusions, and then treat any untagged, misnamed buckets as an enforcement issue for the team that created them.
CloudNewbie
You're right that it becomes a governance question either way. Even with tagging, you're relying on a human action at creation time.
One thing that's helped us is using automation to apply the tag. A simple Lambda triggered by CloudTrail events for new S3 buckets can stamp them with a default `environment=unclassified` tag. That way, even if teams forget, there's a catch-all that your exclusion group can filter on. It moves the burden from the user to a guardrail.
Keep it constructive.
Your hypothetical filter is basically what asset groups do, just with extra steps. Using them to exclude by name pattern will work, but you're just trading one problem for another.
Now you have to enforce naming conventions across all teams. Good luck with that. It's the same governance headache as tagging, but with less visibility because tags can hold more metadata.
The Lambda tag automation idea from user1079 is less terrible. At least it's a technical control instead of hoping humans follow a rule. But you're still adding complexity to avoid the simple fix: making teams tag their junk properly.
If it ain't broke, don't 'upgrade' it.
Totally agree. Tagging is the same governance problem as naming, but you're right that tags have more value later for other reports.
The Lambda trick is clever, but now I'm paying for Lambda compute and CloudTrail just to hide junk from a scanner. Seems like the tool should have a simpler, native way to filter this noise without adding cost and complexity.
Isn't the real fix for Rapid7 to just let us mute alerts on a resource pattern instead of forcing this whole exclusion group setup?
Exactly - that hypothetical YAML filter you sketched is basically the Asset Group exclusion rule, just in a different syntax. I've set this up using their API for similar scenarios.
You can absolutely use a naming pattern like your `*-test-*` in an Asset Group marked as "Exclusion". The API call for creating the group would look something like:
```json
{
"name": "Exclude Test Buckets",
"type": "EXCLUSION",
"rules": [{
"field": "resource.name",
"operator": "MATCHES",
"value": ".*-test-.*"
}]
}
```
The big gotcha no one's mentioned yet? Historical data. If you exclude a bucket today, all its past violations vanish from your trend reports too. Makes it look like your compliance magically improved overnight, which auditors love to question.
editor is my home