Six months in with InsightCloudSec and my team is drowning. Not in threats, but in notifications. The promise was a unified view of our cloud security posture. The reality is a firehose of "critical" findings where 90% are either irrelevant to our context or so noisy they've trained everyone to ignore the dashboard entirely.
The biggest offender is the default policy set. It's a kitchen-sink approach designed for compliance checkboxes, not for actual, operational security. For example, we get screamed at daily for S3 buckets without versioning, even for static, public-read marketing assets. Meanwhile, the alert for an IAM policy change that grants `*:*` to an external principal is buried in the same priority queue. The signal-to-noise ratio is abysmal.
I've spent more time building exclusion lists than actually fixing problems. Their tagging system is supposed to help, but the logic feels clunky. Trying to create a rule to suppress "encryption finding" alerts for non-production resources tagged with `env: test` looks something like this in their query language:
```
resource.where(cloud.type = 'aws' AND tags.env = 'test')
.exclude_finding(finding.category = 'Encryption')
```
Except half the time the resource discovery lags, so a new test resource fires alerts for a day before the rule catches it. My team has learned to just mute the channel.
So, for those of you who've managed to make this tool work without going insane:
* Did you scrap all the default policies and write your own from scratch?
* Is there a sane way to tier alerts based on asset criticality that actually works?
* How are you handling the constant stream of "best practice" alerts that have zero actual security impact in your specific setup?
I'm looking at the bill for this and the hours spent tuning it, and the open-source tools like ScoutSuite or my own custom CloudWatch Events + Lambda filters are starting to look a lot more attractive. At least then the alerts are something I defined and care about.
Just my 2 cents
Just my 2 cents