Just finished a big migration from Mailchimp to Brevo for my main list. Transferred about 50k contacts, and the initial sync gave me a 12% bounce rate right out of the gate. That was a bit of a shock.
Mailchimp had them listed as "subscribed," but Brevo's hygiene check flagged a ton. Mostly invalid emails and some spam traps. Makes you wonder about list decay and how each platform handles it. Has anyone else seen this after a switch? The deliverability feels cleaner now, but that initial number hurt.
dk
dk
Ouch, that's a big bounce rate right away. Makes me think Brevo is just a lot stricter on checks upfront.
I'm about to do a smaller migration and now I'm worried. Did the bounces happen during the import, or did you have to send a campaign first to see them?
The bounces were flagged during the import's initial hygiene scan, not from a send. That's typical for platforms with stricter real-time validation on ingress.
For your smaller migration, you might want to run the list through a separate validation service first. It'll give you a preview and let you clean before hitting Brevo's systems. The upfront hit is better than damaging your sender reputation with a campaign.
Different ESPs have vastly different thresholds for what constitutes a 'valid' address.
sub-100ms or bust
You're correct about Brevo's stricter front end checks. However, the 12% figure likely represents accumulated list decay that Mailchimp was tolerating in a "subscribed" state, not necessarily a new, aggressive policy from Brevo.
If you're worried about your smaller migration, you can test the water. Export a random sample of your list, say 1000 contacts, and run it through Brevo's import process first. That will give you a statistically significant preview of your overall bounce rate without committing the whole list. The discrepancy often comes down to how often an ESP re-validates addresses in a dormant status.
prove it with data
That's a solid point about separate validation. We ran our last migration list through ZeroBounce first and it caught about 8% before we even hit Brevo's import.
One caveat, though - even a clean validation service file can sometimes trip a few extra bounces on import. Brevo's own real-time checks seem to catch role accounts (like info@, support@) that some validators let through. So you might still see a small delta.
Yeah, that initial number is brutal to see. But honestly, that 12% was just sitting there, hurting your deliverability silently in Mailchimp. Brevo just slapped a label on it.
I saw a similar drop moving a list last year. The "cleaner" feeling you mentioned is real - my open rates jumped after the dead weight was gone. Painful but necessary surgery.
Ever look at which segments had the highest bounce concentration? For me it was my oldest "lead magnet" signups. Not shocking, but helpful for future list hygiene.
Trial first, ask later.