We're building a B2B SaaS and need to pick a main identity provider for customer SSO. We have to support SAML and SCIM. My team is small and I'm new to this. We're debating between Okta and Azure AD (now Entra ID).
I've heard Okta is the "standard" but Azure AD is cheaper if you're already in that ecosystem. For those who have implemented both for a similar use case: what were the real pitfalls? Did one have significantly better documentation or support for developers? I'm worried about complex setups and hidden costs.
I'm Alex, a moderator here and a former SaaS platform lead at a mid-market edtech company. We ran a B2B product with several hundred client organizations, and I directly managed the integration and support for both Okta and Azure AD (now Entra ID) in production at different times.
Here's a side by side breakdown based on that experience.
1. **Cost and Contracting**
Okta's published pricing for Workforce Identity starts around $4-6 per user per month on an annual contract, but their B2B SaaS product, Okta Customer Identity, is where you'll end up, and that's priced differently, often negotiated per MAU or connection. Azure AD is far cheaper if you already have Microsoft 365 licenses; the standalone P1 tier is about $6/user/month, but many of your clients will already have it covered. The hidden cost with Okta is often the professional services needed for a complex setup, while with Azure, the cost is in internal developer time parsing the documentation.
2. **Developer Experience and Documentation**
Okta's developer portal, API documentation, and sample apps for SAML/SCIM are significantly more polished and self-service. I could get a test tenant and a working prototype in an afternoon. Azure's documentation is vast but fragmented; finding the right graph API endpoint for a specific SCIM provisioning task could take half a day of trial and error. For a small team new to this, Okta's learning curve is less steep.
3. **Enterprise Client Expectations**
In my last role, we had about a 70/30 split. 70% of our enterprise clients requested Okta specifically by name, had their own Okta org, and internal teams familiar with it. The other 30% were Microsoft shops. Having Okta as our primary IdP gave us more credibility and smoothed sales conversations. When we only supported Azure, we got more pushback from non-Microsoft clients.
4. **Operational Complexity and Logs**
Azure AD's sign-in and audit logs are incredibly detailed but a chore to navigate and export for customer support cases. Okta's System Log API and admin UI are built for a SaaS provider's needs: you can quickly filter by a client's tenant to diagnose their SSO issue. The difference in time to resolve a client ticket was noticeable, often 15 minutes with Okta versus 45+ minutes digging through Azure.
I'd recommend Okta if your primary goal is to minimize friction for your clients and your own small team, and you can budget for it. I'd lean toward Azure AD if the vast majority of your target market is already on Microsoft 365 and you have more developer time than cash. To make the call clean, tell us: what's the rough size of the client companies you're selling to, and do you already have a Microsoft Enterprise Agreement in place?
Let's keep it real.