Skip to content
Has anyone benchmar...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Has anyone benchmarked the compute cost of Claw's security layers? Ours doubled.

21 Posts
20 Users
0 Reactions
180 Views
(@annac)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 391
 

Oof, that's a rough jump. Seeing the actual numbers from 2.1 to 4.8 seconds explains everything.

The key detail is that 85% peak utilization. It means you're not just adding a fixed cost, you're likely hitting throttling, which inflates duration in a nasty way. You can test this easily: try temporarily bumping your instance size by one tier and see if that 4.8 seconds drops significantly. If it does, your bottleneck is resource contention. If it stays high, the module's logic itself is the real hog.

We saw the exact same pattern. Our fix was a multi-tiered approach:
- First, we trimmed the default PII pattern list to the 15 types we actually care about.
- Then we set a payload size threshold and skip the heavy scan for small, low-risk internal traffic.
- Finally, we re-provisioned the underlying compute with more headroom, but *after* the other optimizations. Doing it in that order saved us about 60% of the projected "just scale up" cost.

Have you looked at your traffic mix to see what percentage of calls are actually carrying high-risk PII? That's usually the real eye-opener.


Keep it simple.


   
ReplyQuote
(@david_chen_data)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 401
 

Your baseline utilization of 45% is the starting point for the problem. That's not a stable baseline; it's a pre-loaded platform with insufficient headroom. When you add any fixed computational overhead, like regex scanning, you're not just adding cost, you're pushing into the non-linear part of the performance curve where throttling dominates.

The cost doubling is the symptom. The root is that your initial sizing didn't account for the combined workload of baseline processing plus security scanning. You need to treat the security module's compute profile as a fixed addition to your base requirements, not as a simple multiplier. Profile the PII scanner in isolation on your median payload to get its standalone cost, then add that to your original 45% to see your new target utilization floor before you even consider traffic spikes.


data is the product


   
ReplyQuote
(@ethanc)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 189
 

Spot on about the *combination* of size and frequency being the real load profile. That's where the actual monthly bill lives, not in the scary one-off spikes.

Your point reminds me of a trap we fell into: we optimized our scanning logic around a beautiful, clean JSON structure for our largest payloads. But then the constant churn of messy, nested, real-world average traffic - which processed faster individually - ended up dominating the total compute minutes because of its sheer volume. The median churn can quietly drown you.

So now we profile both, and weight the cost projection by the actual distribution. It's the only way to get a number that doesn't surprise you later.


Test, measure, repeat


   
ReplyQuote
(@fionaj)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 203
 

Oh, that's a really good point about the baseline! So you're saying that 45% baseline utilization is already too high to safely add a fixed cost module? I never thought of it that way before.

So profiling the PII scanner alone and then adding that cost to the baseline would give you the real "new normal," not the best case scenario. That makes the cost doubling seem almost inevitable if you're starting that high.

Is there a rule of thumb for a safe baseline utilization when you know you'll be adding modules like this?



   
ReplyQuote
(@alexc)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 341
 

We saw the same cost curve, but for us the TLS inspection was the hidden beast, not PII. The handshake overhead per connection absolutely crushed our high-throughput microservice chatter. Had to implement a mutual TLS cache at the edge, which cut about 40% of the new overhead back.

That peak utilization jump to 85% is the red flag. You're likely paying for throttling, not just raw compute. Did you try scaling the instance up as a quick test to see if the task duration drops? If it does, you might just be resource-starved.


Automate everything.


   
ReplyQuote
(@ellej)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 272
 

Exactly. The "peak vCPU ~85%" figure screams throttling. That's not just adding compute, you're paying a penalty for hitting the ceiling.

Before you over-engineer the scanning logic, just bump the instance size for a single test run. If the 4.8 second duration drops by, say, a full second, you've found a quick, albeit expensive, fix.

If it stays stubbornly high, then your battle is with the Shield module's own code efficiency. That's a much tougher conversation with Claw support.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 2