Hi everyone, new to the security scanning side of things here. We're a small team with a Java and Kotlin monorepo, currently using SonarQube for code quality. Management is now asking for better dependency and secrets scanning, and someone mentioned Apiiro.
From what I've read, SonarQube seems strong on code smells and basic vulnerabilities, while Apiiro talks a lot about risk context and supply chain. But it's hard to find direct comparisons.
For those who have used both, especially with JVM languages:
* Is Apiiro's security scanning (for things like secrets in commits) that much more comprehensive?
* How do they compare on false positives for dependency vulnerabilities in a monorepo?
* Does it make sense to run both, or is that overkill for a team just starting to formalize security?
Just trying to understand if Apiiro is a complete replacement or a specialized add-on. Any practical experience would be a huge help.
?^?
Still learning.
I'm a product manager at a mid-sized fintech, and we run a Java/Kotlin monorepo with about 25 devs. We piloted Apiiro and have used SonarQube Cloud for two years.
**Main purpose**: SonarQube is primarily a code quality and basic SAST tool. Apiiro is a risk platform focused on secrets, supply chain, and IaC. In our pilot, Apiiro caught 3 leaked API keys in old commits that Sonar never flagged.
**Dependency scanning accuracy**: For Java/Kotlin, SonarQube (using its OWASP integration) had more false positives on monorepo transitive dependencies. Apiiro's contextual analysis (knowing what's in prod) reduced noise by about 40% for us.
**Setup and cost**: SonarQube Cloud runs about $12/user/month for our tier. Apiiro's sales quote started at $45k/year minimum, which is a completely different price league.
**Real limitation**: Apiiro is heavier on integration (needs your SCM, CI/CD, and cloud to provide context). It took us 3 weeks to get fully connected. SonarQube was a CI plugin we added in an afternoon.
I'd recommend starting with SonarQube and adding a dedicated secrets scanner like GitGuardian or TruffleHog. For a team just formalizing security, Apiiro is overkill unless you're in a heavily regulated industry. To make a clean call, tell us your team's security maturity and your annual security tool budget.
Thanks for the breakdown, especially on the cost and setup time. That price difference is huge. I'm curious, since you mentioned adding a dedicated secrets scanner instead of Apiiro, does that mean you're now running three tools: SonarQube for quality/SAST, a secrets scanner, and then something else for dependency scanning? Or does SonarQube plus the secrets tool cover most of your bases?