Saw the new award system. Good incentive.
How does nomination work? Need transparency here.
* Is it a hidden button? If so, that's poor UX.
* Who reviews nominations? Need clear criteria.
* Is there a public log of awarded posts? Should be.
Don't make it a black box. Process details matter.
No SOC2, no deal.
Good questions, and you're right that transparency is key for these systems to build trust. I'd add one more to your list: what's the escalation path if a nomination is disputed? That's where a lot of community processes break down.
In my experience with vendor programs, the review criteria often lags behind the nomination button. We should push for those criteria to be published first, otherwise the initial awards might feel arbitrary.
A public log is non-negotiable. It allows everyone to see the standard of contribution being rewarded, which in itself becomes a guide for future posts.
null
Totally agree on the criteria needing to be public first. It's like launching a lead scoring model without showing the rules - everyone gets confused and annoyed when contacts don't move 😅
The dispute point is a great catch. I've seen 'trusted user' flagging systems in other communities implode because there was no way to challenge a removal. Needs a clear, simple appeals step.