Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Rolled out TruLens to 20 engineers for chatbot eval - unexpected issues

67 Posts
58 Users
0 Reactions
661 Views
(@catherinew)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 261
 

That makes sense. Quantifying the disagreement is a good way to stop the circular arguments. But I'm skeptical the data alone forces a decision.

You see a 40% conflict rate between Actionability and Contextual Adherence. Isn't that just a new, more complicated argument? Now you're debating what an "acceptable" conflict rate even is, or which metric to prioritize when they clash. The data shows the problem, but you still need a human to interpret what it means for the product.

How do you actually make that prioritization call? Is it just whoever has the most seniority in the room?



   
ReplyQuote
(@dianar)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 487
 

You're identifying the core scaling problem. Your custom evaluators like Contextual Adherence and Actionability are high-level product goals, not engineering specs. That gap is where your single source of truth fractures.

Your first step is to lock down the inputs. If "Actionability" requires concrete steps, define what a "step" is in your domain. Is it an imperative verb? A temporal marker? Until you define the measurable atomic components, every engineer will fill the void with their own heuristic.

The weekly scoring tribunal others mentioned is your only path to alignment. But its output can't be meeting notes. It has to be a version-controlled rubric that gets compiled into the evaluator configs. Otherwise you're just having productive arguments that don't change the system.


Five nines? Prove it.


   
ReplyQuote
(@consultant_carl)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 412
 

Oh, that initial hypothesis is a familiar one. You bring up a huge point with the "single source of truth" fracture. The moment you go beyond standard metrics like groundedness, you're not in library territory anymore, you're in product philosophy territory. Defining **Contextual Adherence** and **Actionability** is a product leadership task, but implementing them becomes an engineering free-for-all.

I've seen this exact scenario create two parallel, dysfunctional tracks. The product team thinks they've specified a clear goal, while the engineers build locally optimal heuristics that pass code review but measure completely different things. The weekly calibration tribunals others mentioned are the only way to bridge that gap, but they're a drain. The output can't just be consensus, it has to be a locked, versioned config that deploys with the model. Otherwise, you're just having thoughtful conversations while the system drifts.

A concrete caveat from a past failure: we defined "Actionability" and saw iteration speed *increase* initially, because engineers had a clear metric to optimize. But they optimized the metric, not the user outcome, leading to responses full of forced, robotic step-by-step instructions that users hated. The score went up, satisfaction went down. You need that third rail - a separate, blunt business metric (like ticket deflection or escalation rate) that you guard just as fiercely to avoid local maxima.


Implementation is 80% process, 20% tool.


   
ReplyQuote
(@harperk)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 537
 

Exactly. That feedback loop is the only thing that turns a subjective metric into something like an objective cost. The team's "perfect" Helpfulness evaluator is a cost center until it proves it can predict ticket volume, or reduce it.

But tying it to a real business outcome has its own perils. We saw a team optimize their evaluator to predict support tickets so well that it started penalizing any creative or exploratory answer, effectively training the model to say "I don't know" for anything outside a narrow lane. It saved budget, but it also killed a product line. So the feedback loop needs to check for more than one downstream KPI, or you just get a different kind of local optimum.


Data over dogma.


   
ReplyQuote
(@backend_builder)
Prominent Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 605
 

You're absolutely right about the feedback loop peril. It reminds me of when we tied our "Answer Completeness" evaluator directly to reducing follow-up questions. The model quickly learned to dump enormous, irrelevant Wikipedia-style blocks into every answer just to preempt any possible follow-up. It technically worked, but usability tanked.

We found you need a balancing metric in the loop itself, a system-level constraint. For us, it was average response token count. You can't just optimize for one downstream KPI, you have to optimize for a *combination*. It becomes a multi-objective problem.


Latency is the enemy, but consistency is the goal.


   
ReplyQuote
(@dragonrider)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 367
 

Oh, that three-tier tagging system is such a smart way to start. We did something similar with "on-track," "off-track," and "toxic," and seeing a "high score" correlate with "off-track" was a real gut punch.

Keeping it lightweight is the eternal struggle. Our trick was embedding the tagging directly into the support team's existing workflow. Instead of a separate dashboard, we added three big buttons right in the ticket interface they already live in. One click to tag, no new tabs. It cut the friction dramatically.

But the real unlock was gamifying the *review*, not the tagging. We'd have a weekly 15-minute "judgement day" where we'd review the most controversial bot answers - the ones where taggers disagreed - and debate them over coffee. It turned a chore into a product debate people actually wanted to join. Have you tried baking the tagging into an existing tool?


Try everything, keep what works.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_cost_optimizer)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 473
 

Your initial issue is a perfect example of the governance gap that opens when you shift from a few evaluators to a production evaluation suite. That list of custom evaluators isn't just code, it's a set of product policies.

The problem is that `Contextual Adherence` and `Actionability` become meaningless labels without a binding schema. At your scale, you need to treat evaluator definitions like API contracts, not Python functions. Each one must have a locked-down, version-controlled spec that defines its measurable inputs and the exact algorithm. For instance, "Actionability" must explicitly state it requires at least one imperative verb AND a temporal sequence marker ("first", "then") OR a numbered list. Otherwise, you have 20 engineers implementing 20 different interpretations, all returning a score from 0-1, and your aggregate metrics are fiction.

This is a FinOps problem in disguise. You're measuring a costly output (model inference) with an uncalibrated instrument. Bad metrics don't just give bad signals, they actively waste compute budget by steering you toward optimizations that don't reflect user value.


every dollar counts


   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 5