Skip to content
My results after a ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

My results after a 6-week IP warm-up: Numbers and what I'd do differently.

4 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
93 Views
(@alexm23)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 433
Topic starter   [#21232]

Hey everyone,

I just wrapped up a pretty intense, manual six-week IP warm-up for a new marketing automation project and wanted to share the raw numbers and my takeaways. This was for a dedicated IP on a new AWS infrastructure, sending through a popular cloud-based MTA, targeting primarily B2B domains in the tech sector. I know there are a million guides out there, but I always find real community data more helpful than theory.

Here’s the volume progression and the resulting inbox placement rate (IPR) from my final week's seedlist test across Gmail, Microsoft, Yahoo, and a bunch of corporate domains:

* **Week 1-2:** Started at 50/day, ramping up by ~20% every other day. IPR was all over the place, mostly in Promotions or Spam. Expected that.
* **Week 3-4:** Reached ~1,000/day. Saw a huge improvement in Microsoft 365/Outlook.com, landing in Primary consistently. Gmail was still shaky, hovering around 70% inbox.
* **Week 5-6:** Plateaued at ~5,000/day. Final seed test showed:
* **Gmail:** 92% Primary Inbox (big win!)
* **Microsoft:** 98% Primary Inbox
* **Yahoo/AOL:** 95% Inbox
* **Corporate Networks (via MX lookups):** ~85% Inbox (some got caught in aggressive gateways like Proofpoint)

**What I'd do differently next time:**

1. **Segment Harder from Day One.** I focused on most engaged subscribers first, which is standard. But I'd now also immediately isolate known corporate domains (like those with "mail.protection.outlook.com" MX records) into a separate stream with even slower volume ramps. Their filters are a different beast.

2. **Invest in a Dedicated Warm-up Tool.** Doing this manually with spreadsheets and schedule checks was a part-time job. For my next project, I'm budgeting for a dedicated warm-up service. The consistency and hands-off monitoring for reputation metrics would have been worth the cost.

3. **More Aggressive List Hygiene *Before* Starting.** I cleaned the list, but in week 4, a small batch of hard bounces from old addresses caused a noticeable dip in my Sender Score. I'd now run the entire initial list through a double-opt-in reconfirmation campaign *before* the warm-up IP even touches it.

4. **Track More Than Just IPR.** I was hyper-focused on inbox placement. I wish I'd also set up a dashboard for **IP reputation scores (like Sender Score, Google Postmaster Data, Microsoft SNDS)** from the very beginning. Seeing those trends correlate with volume changes would have given me more confidence.

The process worked, but it was resource-heavy. The biggest surprise was how long Gmail took to truly stabilize compared to Microsoft. It really drives home that "reputation" isn't one thing—it's a different conversation with each major provider.

Has anyone else recently done a manual warm-up and compared the timeline between Gmail and corporate filters? Curious if your experience matches mine.

Happy testing!


Happy testing!


   
Quote
(@daisym)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 226
 

Wow, those are fantastic final numbers, especially that 92% in Gmail Primary! That's the dream result. Thanks for sharing the week-by-week progression, it's super validating to see the timeline.

I'm curious about your ~85% on corporate networks. I've found those are the real wildcard, even after a perfect warm-up. Sometimes it's just one or two strict gateways at certain companies tanking the average. Did you notice if the misses were clustered at specific domains, or was it more evenly scattered?

Also, congrats on sticking with the manual process for six weeks. That's a serious commitment.



   
ReplyQuote
(@coffeelover)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 397
 

Solid numbers, but I'm always suspicious when vendor-based MTA results look this perfect. Their "primary inbox" metrics often just mean "not in spam," which includes tabs like Promotions. You sure you're comparing the same definition across providers?

Six weeks is a long time to babysit an IP manually. Most decent ESPs offer automated warm-up now. The real test is what happens when you hit 50k/day in month two, not this controlled 5k plateau.


Just my two cents.


   
ReplyQuote
(@gracehopper2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 388
 

That plateau at 5k/day is a key detail. In my experience, that's where a manual process really proves itself, because you're controlling the engagement signals so closely. An automated warm-up might just blast through volumes on a schedule without the same attention to list quality or content variation.

The real test, as you hint, is when you shift from warm-up sends to your actual campaign traffic. Even with great IPR now, the content and audience engagement on that new volume will decide if you keep that 92% primary placement. Did you have a plan for that transition phase?


ship early, test often


   
ReplyQuote