Skip to content
Opinion: The shift ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Opinion: The shift to API-based attacks makes old signature rules useless.

2 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
64 Views
(@billyp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 284
Topic starter   [#15189]

Okay, this might ruffle some feathers, but hear me out. I come from the email marketing automation world, where we've seen this same evolution. We used to block based on simple "signatures" – a sketchy sender domain, a known malicious link in the body. It's like the old WAF rules looking for `' OR '1'='1` in a URL.

The game changed when attacks started mimicking *good* traffic. In email, it's phishing links hidden behind legitimate-looking click-tracking domains. On the web, it's the shift to API-based attacks. The malicious payload isn't in some weird, malformed URL you can regex. It's a perfectly structured JSON POST request to `/api/v1/login` or `/graphql`. The attack surface is now the *logic* of your application, not its front door.

Think about it:
* An attacker can hammer your login API with a list of stolen credentials (credential stuffing) at a low, slow rate from thousands of IPs. No malformed SQL to detect.
* They can abuse a forgot-password endpoint to spam users. No XSS signature to trigger.
* They can exploit business logic – like adding negative quantities to a cart – via a normal API call.

Old signature-based WAF rules are blind to this. They're looking for the wrong thing in the wrong place. It's like trying to stop a sophisticated phishing campaign by only checking the "From:" address.

The new playbook has to be about understanding **normal** API behavior for *your* app – baseline request rates, sequence, payload size – and then spotting anomalies. It's less about known bad patterns and more about spotting "impossible" or abusive flows that violate your business logic.

So, what are you all doing to adapt? Are you moving more towards behavioral/rate-based rules at the edge, or is the solution shifting to the origin with better instrumentation in the app itself?

Billy


Always A/B test.


   
Quote
(@heidir33)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 270
 

That's a really strong comparison to email. It makes perfect sense. In my area, we saw the exact same pivot when platforms started flagging based on content patterns alone. They'd look for words like "urgent" or "click here," so the bad actors just stopped using those words. The malicious intent was entirely separate from the literal text.

Your point about the attack surface moving to the *logic* is what makes this so hard. A signature rule can't understand that a "forgot password" request every 30 seconds from the same IP for 100 different users is an abuse of intended functionality. It's a perfectly valid request, every single time. The threat is in the pattern of usage, not the payload.

I'm curious, though, from your perspective: if signature-based rules are becoming blind, what's filling the gap? Is it purely behavioral analysis and rate limiting at the API gateway level, or are there new types of signals we should be looking for in those JSON bodies that aren't simple string matches?



   
ReplyQuote