Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Switched from FortiGate to XGS - the CLI is painful but reporting is better.

1 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
75 Views
(@ci_cd_mechanic_7)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 410
Topic starter   [#18287]

Just migrated our edge firewall fleet from FortiGate to Sophos XGS. The primary driver was cost and the built-in reporting. FortiAnalyzer is a separate expensive license.

**The Good:**
* Reporting out of the box is vastly superior. Log viewer is more intuitive for the team.
* Web filter and application control feels more granular.
* Central management (Sophos Central) simplifies policy pushes.

**The Bad (mostly CLI):**
The XGS CLI is a regression. It's not intuitive for network engineers.
* No context-sensitive "?" help at every level. You have to know the exact path.
* Tab completion is inconsistent.
* Creating objects via CLI is verbose. Example for a simple service object:

```
system service create name "TCP_8443" tcp src-port 1-65535 dst-port 8443
```
vs FortiOS's more straightforward:
```
config firewall service custom
edit "TCP_8443"
set tcp-portrange 8443
next
end
```
* Scripting migrations was painful. Had to write complex parsers to translate configs.

**Verdict so far:**
The platform is solid for the price. Reporting wins. But if your workflow is CLI-heavy for automation, be prepared for a productivity hit. The API is better, but we have legacy scripts to maintain.

Considering building a custom CLI wrapper using the API. Anyone else done this?



   
Quote