Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Comparison: S1's forensics data quality vs. a traditional full-disk image.

4 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
78 Views
(@fionap)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 349
Topic starter   [#10949]

Hey everyone! I've been knee-deep in incident response lately, and it sparked a conversation in our team that I thought was worth bringing here. We were debating the trade-offs between using SentinelOne's built-in forensics data (the Deep Visibility stuff) versus pulling a traditional, full-disk forensic image.

From a project management and timeline perspective, the difference is huge. With S1's data, I can have an analyst querying process trees, network connections, and file modifications *within minutes* of isolating an endpoint. It's like having a pre-sorted, searchable log of "interesting" events leading up to the alert. For getting a rapid answer to "what happened?" and scope containment, it's incredible.

But when we needed absolute, undeniable legal-grade evidence for a serious case, our external counsel still insisted on a physical image. Their point was about data completeness and chain of custody in a courtroom. S1's telemetry is rich, but it's a *subset* of activity—it shows you what the agent saw and recorded. A full-disk image is the entire universe of data at a point in time, including slack space, deleted files not yet overwritten, and everything outside S1's policy scope.

So here’s my practical comparison based on our last two incidents:

**For speed and operational response (most cases):**
* **S1 Forensics:** Immediate. Query across the entire fleet. Perfect for understanding the "blast radius" and crafting IoC searches.
* **Traditional Image:** Hours to acquire, plus more hours to analyze. Stops the response dead while you wait.

**For comprehensiveness and legal hold:**
* **S1 Forensics:** Might miss artifacts if they weren't deemed "suspicious" by policy at the time. You're working with the data S1 collected.
* **Traditional Image:** Defensible. Contains everything. Often required for regulatory or criminal proceedings.

Our workflow now is to use S1's data for 95% of our investigations and only image when legal explicitly demands it. It's saved us hundreds of hours.

Has anyone else settled on a similar hybrid approach? Or have you found ways to configure S1's data collection to be robust enough to *replace* imaging for certain compliance frameworks? I'd love to compare notes!

🌻 fiona


null


   
Quote
(@benchmark_bob_42)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 433
 

I'm a senior incident responder at a 15k-employee tech company, and we've standardized on SentinelOne across our Windows/Linux fleet, where I run its forensics data against traditional images in live exercises and after-action reviews.

* **Completeness of Evidence**: A full-disk image is a bit-for-bit copy, capturing the entire state, including unallocated space and memory artifacts if done live. S1's telemetry is a curated subset, typically capturing process creation, network connections, file modifications, and registry changes based on its policy. In a recent case, the image contained a deleted script in slack space that S1 had not logged as a file event because it was executed and deleted within a single second.
* **Time to First Answer**: S1's Deep Visibility console can be queried for event timelines within 2-3 minutes of an alert. For a traditional image, the acquisition time alone for a 512 GB drive over a 1 Gbps network is roughly 1.5 hours, not including the subsequent imaging and analysis setup.
* **Legal Admissibility Weight**: Our external legal counsel consistently demands a physical image for any case they anticipate entering litigation. Their position is that the documented chain of custody from a write-blocked acquisition, and the reproducibility of findings from a raw image, is the standard. S1's JSON logs, while detailed, are treated as supporting telemetry, not the primary evidence.
* **Operational Cost & Scope**: Taking a full-disk image requires isolating the endpoint for the duration of acquisition (often hours), which is a major business disruption. Using S1's data allows investigation while the host remains in production, with near-zero operational impact. The hidden cost is the storage for images; we budget about $0.023/GB/month for long-term evidence retention in cold storage, which adds up fast.

For rapid triage, containment, and understanding attacker TTPs, I default to S1's data. For any incident with a credible likelihood of litigation or regulatory action, I immediately escalate for a traditional image. To make a clean call, tell us your mean time-to-containment SLA and whether you have a regulatory requirement to preserve evidence in a specific format.


-- bb42


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_security_sera)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 543
 

Your point about "legal admissibility weight" is exactly why we still keep our imaging kits. The legal team's requirement for a physical image isn't just about the evidence itself. It's about defensible process.

If you're in a hearing and have to explain your curated EDR telemetry, you're already in a weaker position than someone who can state they preserved the entire physical state. The chain of custody for an image is simpler to document and harder to challenge.

The script in slack space example is good. S1's policy-based logging is a filter, and filters have gaps. You can't query for data it never collected.


Least privilege is not a suggestion.


   
ReplyQuote
(@emmae)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 255
 

Oh, that's a really good point about the legal process being a separate hurdle from just having the data. I hadn't considered how explaining the telemetry filter itself could be a weakness.

So it sounds like the S1 data is fantastic for the *technical* answer on what happened, but the traditional image is for the *procedural* answer of how you know. Is that a fair way to think about it?

That makes me wonder, for those "serious cases" mentioned earlier, do teams typically run both in parallel? Like, use S1 for the immediate investigation and still pull the image for the legal file?



   
ReplyQuote