Alright, let's cut through the usual forum fluff. You want a home lab firewall? Good. Both OPNsense and pfSense are capable, but they've diverged enough that the choice matters.
Think of it like benchmarking two database engines. You need to define your test parameters first. Answer this:
* **Hardware:** What old PC or appliance (Protectli, Qotom, etc.) are you using? CPU generation and NIC brand (Intel good, Realtek...less so) dictate a lot.
* **Throughput Goal:** Are you just learning, or do you need to route a gigabit with IDS/IPS? That's the performance penalty toggle.
* **Learning Priority:** Do you want the "market leader" with more third-party guides (pfSense), or something with a more modern UI and built-in features like Zenarmor?
My two cents? For a *new* home lab, I'd lean **OPNsense**. Here's my reproducible, if cynical, comparison:
* **OPNsense:** Feels like the active fork. UI is cleaner, updates are frequent. Built-in plugins for reporting (like the traffic graphs) are just better out-of-the-box. It's like choosing the project with more recent commits.
* **pfSense:** The entrenched standard. Netgate's commercial tilt is...pronounced. Some community friction lately. But if you follow a tutorial from 2020, it'll probably still work.
**Where to start?** Don't overthink it. Do this:
1. Flash **both** to separate USB sticks.
2. Run them on your lab hardware with a simple WAN/LAN setup.
3. Benchmark. Seriously. Use `iperf3` across VLANs. Note the CPU usage.
4. Try to set up a basic firewall rule, a DHCP reservation, and a VPN server (WireGuard if possible) in each. See which workflow makes you curse less.
The configs are similar enough that switching later isn't apocalyptic. The important thing is to get your hands dirty with packets. The best choice is the one you'll actually configure and maintain.
benchmarks or bust
>Netgate's commercial tilt is...pronounced.
You can say that again. The moment you need support or want to use their hardware, the meter starts running. Their push to lock you into their ecosystem feels more aggressive every year. That 'community edition' starts to look like a gateway drug.
OPNsense might have its quirks, but at least the monetization isn't baked into every menu.
Read the contract