Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Hot take: Their marketing promises 'auto-fix', but it's just PRs.

37 Posts
35 Users
0 Reactions
388 Views
(@backend_latency_queen)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 613
 

You're spot on about the PR debt. I'd add that the queue management problem gets worse at scale. If you're generating dozens of PRs a week, the review latency becomes a dominant factor in your team's cycle time. It's not just noise, it's an uncontrolled, high-priority workstream that can starve your actual feature development.

The CI failure point is critical. A tool that doesn't model the full dependency graph, including your locked production toolchain, is producing invalid suggestions. That turns "automation" into a manual triage job, where you're debugging their fixes. It adds latency, not reduces it.


sub-100ms or bust


   
ReplyQuote
(@danielm)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 453
 

Exactly, the baseline is everything. Sales keeps quoting total hours saved on manual scans like it's pure profit, but they never factor in the cognitive loan sharking of constant context switches. The "undisturbed time blocks" metric is the only honest one.

We tried a similar approach with a code review bot. The vendor's dashboard showed "150 hours saved!" That number assumed every review alert was a self-contained, five minute task. It completely ignored the 20-minute ramp-up each time to re-load the codebase into my brain, which turned their "savings" into a net loss.

Your calendar method is good, but it assumes you can even get a clean baseline. Good luck getting a week without some other vendor's "auto-fix" queue already bleeding your attention dry.


— skeptical but fair


   
ReplyQuote
(@infra_architect_rebel)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 544
 

Forget "deployed to production". You can't contract that. Your ops team isn't their subcontractor.

The only metric you might get is "PR merged". Even that's a fight, because they'll argue your team controls the merge button.

The real fix? Stop buying tools based on their "remediated" dashboard. Measure the tool by what it actually does: accurate findings. Let your own pipeline handle the fix, if it even needs one. Half these vulns are in dev dependencies that never ship.


Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication


   
ReplyQuote
(@emmae)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 255
 

This is such a good way to put it. I'm still new to this, and my team's talking about one of these tools. I got excited about the "auto-fix" part because our review queue is already so slow.

But you're right, it's just moving the work. If we're already drowning in PRs, getting more of them faster doesn't help. It just makes the notification noise worse.

How do you even measure if a tool like this is *actually* saving time, versus just creating a different kind of work? Is it just about counting fewer manual scans, or is there a way to track the context switching cost?



   
ReplyQuote
(@integrations_ivan)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 242
 

Tracking PR latency is a start, but it's a lagging indicator. The true cost is in the cognitive load before the PR even gets opened: the time spent parsing the alert, understanding the proposed fix's side-effects, and assessing the deployment context. That's where the mental tax compounds.

A more direct, if crude, measure is to track the "time to confident decision" for a sample of these auto-generated PRs. Compare it against the time for a traditional, self-initiated dependency update. You'll often find the auto-PR takes longer because you're reverse-engineering their logic instead of building your own.

The real irony is that this creates a new data consistency problem. The tool's model of a "fix" and your production environment's actual state become two disparate systems that you, the engineer, are now manually integrating. You've traded a scanning backlog for a synchronization backlog.


Single source of truth is a myth.


   
ReplyQuote
(@averyd)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 477
 

The vendor's incentive is always to optimize for the metric they control, which is why "remediated" defaults to "PR opened." Tying payment to deployment creates an unmanageable shared risk model they'll avoid.

A more viable, though still difficult, contractual lever is to define their SLA around the *quality* of the generated fix. For example, stipulating that a certain percentage of auto-PRs must pass your standard CI checks on first submission, without manual intervention. This shifts the burden to their fix logic accurately modeling your environment, not your team's merge velocity. It's a proxy for "technically acceptable," which at least filters out the noise that bloats your backlog.

Even then, you'll face pushback. They'll claim your CI is a black box. But it forces the conversation onto the accuracy of their automation, which is the real product you're buying.


Every dollar counts.


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_skeptic_ray)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 429
 

That cliff graph is the most honest bit of data in this whole conversation. Everyone's talking about averages, but the system failure is binary.

The "review latency" metric is good, but you're still measuring the symptom, not the cause. The root cause is the cognitive queue, not the PR queue. Measuring time to first human reaction just tells you the symptom is getting worse.

The real threshold isn't how many PRs you can open, it's how many your team can mentally juggle before they stop doing novel work and become triage nurses. Your graph probably shows where that switch flipped.


Data skeptic, not a data cynic.


   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 3