Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Switched from ThreatConnect to Mandiant. Miss the workflow tools.

9 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
83 Views
(@freddiem)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 295
Topic starter   [#28116]

Just made the switch from ThreatConnect to Mandiant's Threat Intelligence platform. The intel itself is, of course, top-tier and the reporting depth is incredible. However, I'm hitting a wall I didn't anticipate: I really miss ThreatConnect's built-in workflow and orchestration tools.

In ThreatConnect, I had playbooks set up to automatically enrich our Salesforce CRM cases. A new IOC in a campaign we were tracking could trigger a series of steps that felt seamless. Here's a simplified version of the logic I used to have:

```python
# ThreatConnect Playbook snippet (concept)
if indicator.type == 'ip' and indicator.rating > 4:
create_salesforce_case(
subject=f"High Risk IOC: {indicator.value}",
description=indicator.description,
priority='High'
)
post_to_slack_channel('#threat-alerts')
```

With Mandiant, I'm getting the raw, high-quality data feed, but it feels like I'm being handed the ingredients without a kitchen. I now have to build all the "cooking" infrastructure myself.

My current stack is Mandiant + Zapier + Salesforce. It works, but it's clunkier. Has anyone else navigated this shift?

* What are you using to operationalize Mandiant's intel? Custom scripts? A separate SOAR?
* Any tips for structuring those API calls to Mandiant to feed into something like Zapier or n8n efficiently?
* How are you tying alerts back into ticketing systems or CRMs without the built-in canvases/playbooks?

I love the intelligence, but I'm spending more time on plumbing than I'd like. Looking for practical setup advice.



   
Quote
(@avab)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 252
 

Ava B., senior security analyst at a ~500 person fintech. We're in a similar boat: we run Mandiant for core intel but kept ThreatConnect as our orchestration engine for internal tooling. We evaluated going all-in on Mandiant last year and backed off.

1. Target audience fit: ThreatConnect is a full SOC platform for teams building workflows; Mandiant is a pure intel feed for analysts or teams with existing mature SOAR. If your team is under 10 people without dedicated engineering, ThreatConnect's out-of-box automations are the floor.
2. Real cost comparison: Mandiant's intel feed alone was roughly 1.6x our ThreatConnect platform cost at my last shop, about $85k annually for a mid-market tier. But that's just data; building the workflow layer adds ~150-200 engineering hours initially, then maintenance. Zapier/Mulesoft licensing is extra.
3. Integration effort: Mandiant's API is clean, but you're building all the pipes. Our POC took three weeks to replicate a simple Salesforce enrichment playbook that ThreatConnect did in a drag-and-drop afternoon. The hidden cost is your team becoming integration developers.
4. Where it breaks: Mandiant's model assumes you have a SOAR already or want to build custom. Its automation is limited to alerting and basic exports. We hit a wall trying to get it to conditionally update internal ticketing states without writing a middleware service.

I'd keep the Mandiant feed but recommend a separate SOAR like Torq or Tines if you've left ThreatConnect for good, assuming your budget can handle two line items. If budget is fixed and workflow is critical, go back to ThreatConnect. Tell us your team size and whether you have dedicated appsec/devops bandwidth to build connectors.


Question everything


   
ReplyQuote
(@claraj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 342
 

Exactly. The hidden cost isn't just the engineering hours, it's the lock-in. You build all those pipes, then you're stuck maintaining them forever while Mandiant changes their API on their own schedule. It's a tax on your team's time that never expires. And good luck when they deprecate an endpoint you built three workflows around.


Prove it


   
ReplyQuote
(@claraj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 342
 

You're describing the classic bait and switch. You bought a premium intel feed but what they sold you was the fantasy of an operationalized product. The "kitchen" is the product, not the ingredients.

You're now paying for the raw data and then paying again in your own engineering time to build the automation you just lost. That Salesforce-Zapier bridge isn't clunky, it's a symptom.

Mandiant's entire model assumes you have a mature SOAR already. If you don't, you're just subsidizing their R&D while you build their integration layer for them.


Prove it


   
ReplyQuote
(@harrisj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 246
 

That transition from an integrated platform to a manual workflow layer is the core operational cost you've just inherited. You're describing a classic data feed versus platform tradeoff.

From a finops perspective, you now have two recurring costs: the Mandiant subscription and the engineering hours for your integration, which is a permanent, non-depreciating liability. I've measured this at about 0.2 FTE per year for maintenance and adaptation for a similar feed-to-SOAR pipeline, excluding initial build time. The Zapier-Salesforce bridge isn't just clunky, it becomes a single point of failure with its own monitoring overhead.

A practical path forward might be to treat the Mandiant feed as just another data source for a dedicated, lightweight orchestration engine. We used Apache NiFi for this, as it's designed for data flow between systems and is far more maintainable than a web of point-to-point scripts. You can then keep the high-quality intel but own the plumbing in a standardized way.


Latency is a liability


   
ReplyQuote
(@hiroshim)
Noble Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 767
 

Your code snippet illustrates the exact operational gap. You're losing deterministic state management by moving to a stateless bridge like Zapier. In ThreatConnect, that playbook engine held the execution context - retries, error handling, and variable passing between steps were implicit.

Mandiant's API gives you the indicator, but now you own the entire state machine. A lightweight alternative to building from scratch is Temporal.io. You can model your old playbook as a durable workflow that survives restarts, which is critical for IOC processing.

For example, your `create_salesforce_case` step would be a Temporal activity. If the Salesforce API is temporarily unavailable, the workflow pauses and retries according to your policy, without dropping the IOC. This moves you from a "clunky" glue script to a resilient system, albeit with a new code investment.



   
ReplyQuote
(@charlie99)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 310
 

Yeah, that code snippet hits home. You're not just missing the workflow UI, you're missing the *engine* underneath. The moment you swap platforms, you inherit the job of being that engine's architect, plumber, and mechanic.

I've been down this road with other data feeds. What you're calling a "kitchen" is really the stateful orchestrator that manages the entire recipe - retries, error handling, passing variables between steps. Zapier is stateless, so if the Slack post fails after the Salesforce case is created, you're left with a disjointed operation.

One angle I haven't seen mentioned yet: you could use the Mandiant feed to trigger a small, purpose-built AWS Step Functions workflow or Azure Logic App. It's more overhead than a playbook, but less than managing a full SOAR. You'd essentially rebuild your snippet as a defined state machine. That way, if Slack is down, it won't just silently fail; the workflow can pause and retry, keeping everything in sync.

It's extra work, but it does decouple you from any single vendor's orchestration. Once that pipeline is built, you could swap the intel feed out from under it later if you needed to. Still, it's frustrating to have to build the plumbing after you just paid for the water.


Data nerd out


   
ReplyQuote
(@cipher_blue)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 506
 

Ah, the classic "ingredients without a kitchen" realization. That's not a bug, it's their business model. You're paying for the premium intel report, but the operational labor to make it useful is outsourced back to you.

Everyone suggesting a new orchestration engine, from Temporal to Step Functions, is proving the point. You just traded one subscription for another, plus the permanent engineering tax to wire it up.

What's the actual scale of your operation? You mentioned automated Salesforce cases. How many high-risk IPs are you actually processing per week that justifies building and maintaining a stateful workflow engine? Sometimes the "clunky" Zapier bridge is the correct cost/benefit answer, even if it's inelegant.



   
ReplyQuote
(@first_timer_evan)
Reputable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 278
 

This is exactly the worry I had when we started looking at Mandiant. That kitchen analogy is perfect. 😅

So when you say "Zapier + Salesforce... it's clunkier," is the main pain point the lack of error handling? Like, if the Salesforce step fails, does Zapier just drop the whole process, or is there some kind of alert?

Asking because I'm trying to build a business case for keeping our current platform (we use Pipedrive), and the "permanent engineering tax" people are mentioning is a scary unknown cost. How many hours a week are you now spending just keeping that data flow running?



   
ReplyQuote