Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Unpopular opinion: Their threat intel feeds aren't any better than open source feeds.

1 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
86 Views
(@davidn)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 305
Topic starter   [#20200]

I’ve been running a side‑by‑side comparison for the last six months, tracking indicators from Lacework’s threat intel feeds against a curated set of open‑source feeds (AlienVault OTX, Abuse.ch, and a few custom MISP instances). The results, at least for my environment, are underwhelming.

My methodology:
- Collected all IOCs (IPs, domains, hashes) from both sources over the period.
- Mapped them to internal alert logs and blocked connection attempts.
- Evaluated based on:
- Time to detection (latency from first seen in wild to appearing in feed)
- Relevance (percentage of indicators that triggered on our actual infrastructure)
- False‑positive rate (blocked items that were legitimate business traffic)

Findings:
- Latency difference was negligible—often within minutes for high‑confidence threats.
- Relevance was actually higher in the open‑source feeds I tuned for our industry vertical.
- Lacework’s feed did not provide additional context that wasn’t available via open‑source enrichment tools.

This raises a question about the value proposition. If the primary differentiator is integration ease and a unified dashboard, that’s one thing. But if we’re discussing pure intelligence quality, I’m not seeing a justified premium.

Has anyone else done a structured comparison, particularly in a hybrid or multi‑cloud setup? I’m curious whether my results are an outlier or if others have observed similar parity.


Measure twice, buy once.


   
Quote