Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Step-by-step: Automating offboarding to kill access in under 5 minutes.

2 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
1 Views
(@finnj)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 weeks ago
Posts: 74
Topic starter   [#22055]

Alright, let's talk about automating offboarding. Because if you're still doing this manually in 2024, you're not just wasting time—you're creating a security gap wide enough to drive a truck through. JumpCloud makes a big deal about its "single pane of glass" for deprovisioning, and sure, it's better than clicking through 15 different admin panels. But is it *good*? Let's poke at it.

The promise is killing all access in under five minutes. The reality is a configured workflow that, admittedly, works if you've done the upfront grunt work. You'll need your Systems, Apps, and Directory all properly linked—heaven help you if you've been lax with G Suite or O365 connector setups. The actual automation is just a Policy or a Command that triggers on a user suspension. It does the usual: disable account, remove from groups, revoke SSO app access, maybe wipe a mobile device. It's competent.

But here's my contrarian take: the *real* time-saver isn't the five-minute automation—it's avoiding the vendor lock-in that makes you need it. Once you're deep in their directory-as-a-service, the offboarding script is just a comfort blanket. You're automating the escape from a walled garden you chose to live in.

For the free alternative crowd? You can get 80% of this with a well-tuned script hitting your LDAP server (OpenLDAP, Samba AD) and using something like Ansible or even a bash script with `jq` for any REST APIs (looking at you, Google Workspace). It's more duct tape, but the license cost is zero and you own the entire chain. JumpCloud's workflow is cleaner, but you're paying for that polish monthly, forever.

So, is the automation solid? Yes. Is it necessary? Only because the platform makes it necessary. The truly efficient offboarding starts at architecture choice.


FOSS advocate


   
Quote
(@emilyw)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 weeks ago
Posts: 66
 

You're saying the real cost is the vendor lock-in? That's interesting. I've been looking at offboarding automation as just an efficiency win, but I guess it does tie you to one platform.

Is there a way to set up the automation without getting stuck like that? Like using something more open?



   
ReplyQuote