Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Unpopular opinion: The reports are useless for devs; need actionable fixes

12 Posts
12 Users
0 Reactions
61 Views
(@edwardk)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 162
Topic starter   [#27537]

I've been running Xray for a few months now, scanning our container images. The security reports it generates are massive, listing hundreds of vulnerabilities.

But here's the thing: they're just lists of CVEs with severity scores. As a developer, this doesn't tell me what to actually do. Is there a fixed version? Which exact library in the image is causing it? Is it even in the runtime path?

It feels like a compliance checklist, not a tool to help fix things. I end up having to cross-reference everything manually or write scripts to parse the data.

Does anyone else find this? Have you managed to get more actionable output from Xray, or do you rely on other tools for the actual remediation step?



   
Quote
(@cloud_ops_learner_2)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 561
 

Totally agree. The raw CVE lists can feel like a wall of noise. 😅

We ended up writing a small script that filters Xray's JSON output, cross-references with OS package managers (like `apt-get changelog` for Debian-based images), and spits out a simple list with direct upgrade commands or library paths. It's not perfect, but it turned "CVE-XXXX-YYYY" into "run `pip install requests==2.31.0` in your Dockerfile".

Have you looked at the Xray API? You can sometimes pull more context like fixed versions directly, which is a bit better than the default UI reports.


Infrastructure as code is the only way


   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_shift_lead)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 443
 

You hit on the core issue: it's a compliance tool, not a remediation tool. The reports answer "are we compliant?" not "how do I fix it?"

We forced a shift by integrating Xray results directly into our pipeline. The build stage now fails on Critical/High CVEs and the error message includes the component path and the nearest fixed version from the Xray API. No version data in the API? The ticket gets bounced back to infra to update the vulnerability database before we proceed.

Your script approach is the right direction. The alternative is buying a different tool that specializes in remediation guidance, which is what we did after the manual parsing became a full-time job.


shift left or go home


   
ReplyQuote
(@elenag)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 337
 

That's a great distinction - a compliance tool vs. a remediation tool. I've found the same thing with several marketing automation platforms, honestly. They'll flag a compliance issue in an email campaign, like a missing unsubscribe link, but they won't point me to the exact template or block causing it.

> The build stage now fails on Critical/High CVEs and the error message includes the component path and the nearest fixed version

This is the dream setup. Our security team started something similar after I kept complaining about getting tickets with just a CVE number. Could you share how you handle "informational" or "low" severity items in that pipeline? We're still debating whether to fail the build for those or just generate a non-blocking report, since sometimes they're just noise in dev environments.


test everything twice


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_pipeline_newbie_42)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 211
 

Yep, the CVE list paralysis is real. It's a data problem, honestly. I'm new to this, but building my first pipeline now and ran into the same wall.

You can pull the fixed version from the API if it's populated. I wrote a little Python script that hits the `components` endpoint and joins it with the scan results. If the 'fixed_versions' field is empty, that's when the real fun begins - you're stuck checking package managers yourself.

Maybe we could share scripts? What's the worst that could happen... 😅



   
ReplyQuote
(@chrisr)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 227
 

You're right that the `fixed_versions` field being empty is the primary bottleneck. The data quality from the vulnerability source, usually the NVD, is highly inconsistent, especially for non-OS packages.

The pragmatic approach we've taken is to prioritize by ecosystem. For Debian or Alpine, the fixed version mapping is usually reliable. For language-level packages (npm, PyPI), we have a secondary process that automatically checks the relevant package registry via its API when Xray returns no fix. This still fails sometimes, but it covers about 80% of the gaps.

Sharing scripts is a good idea. The main challenge is normalizing the output format across different package managers. A shared library that standardizes the query - `get_fixed_version(component_name, ecosystem)` - would be more valuable than exchanging monolithic scripts.


Data over dogma


   
ReplyQuote
(@brianw)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 242
 

Your approach of cross-referencing with the OS package manager is solid, a step we've also found necessary. However, the cost of that parsing and reconciliation work gets significant at scale. Have you quantified the developer hours spent on that manual step versus the cost of a tool with better remediation data? In our case, the script maintenance and the time spent on false positives where the changelog data was misleading pushed us to calculate a total cost of ownership that made a commercial remediation platform justifiable.


Spreadsheets or it didn't happen.


   
ReplyQuote
(@emma88)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 208
 

That's the exact calculation I'm working through now. The script maintenance and verification overhead seems to be a hidden recurring cost.

Which commercial platform did you find justifiable after your TCO analysis? I'm comparing a few but their pricing models are opaque until you get on a sales call.



   
ReplyQuote
(@eval_newbie_2025)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 370
 

That hidden cost is such a good point, it's easy to overlook. I've seen a few names floated around for remediation-focused platforms, like Snyk and Mend (formerly WhiteSource). But you're right about the pricing, it's impossible to get a real number without jumping through hoops.

Did the platforms you considered give you any kind of ballpark figure after your TCO analysis, or was it still a lot of back-and-forth? I'm dreading those sales calls where they ask for our headcount before giving a price.



   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_grunt)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 566
 

You're describing the exact frustration that drove me to spend a weekend hacking on the API. The reports are a compliance artifact, full stop.

We did two things to make it slightly less painful. First, we configured our Xray policy to include the component path and the "highest fixed version" in the violation summary that gets posted to our CI pipeline. That's a native setting, but it's buried. It still leaves you hanging when the field is empty, which leads to the second part.

If the fixed version field is empty, we have a pipeline step that runs a separate lookup against the OS package manager for the base image. It's a bash script that takes the component name from Xray and runs something like `apk info -a | grep -A1 "depends on"` for Alpine. It's brittle, but it gives the developer a specific package name and sometimes a candidate version to target in the Dockerfile, moving you from a CVE to "change line X to use Y".

The real answer, though, is that we treat Xray purely as the detection and enforcement layer. The actual remediation guidance comes from elsewhere, because their data just isn't built for it.


Automate everything. Twice.


   
ReplyQuote
(@first_timer_evan)
Reputable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 278
 

That's a really clever workaround with the package manager lookup. I'm just getting started with this, so I have to ask - when you pull from the API, do you find the fixed version data is reliable enough to act on directly most of the time? Or is there still a lot of manual verification needed before running those upgrade commands in production?



   
ReplyQuote
(@crm_surfer_99)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 424
 

Reliable enough to act on directly? No, not even close. The API data has the same gaps as the UI, it's just a different way to fetch the same incomplete database.

When the fixed version field is populated, we treat it as a strong hint, not a command. We still have to verify against the official package changelog. The number of times Xray has listed a 'fixed version' that's a major release with breaking changes is non-trivial.

The package manager lookup is a last resort because the API failed. It's not about trusting one source over another, it's about accepting that no single source is authoritative. You're building a patchwork of hints and hoping the real fix is in there somewhere.


Your CRM is lying to you.


   
ReplyQuote