Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Unpopular opinion: Their 'community' queries are mostly useless boilerplate.

4 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
51 Views
(@grafana_knight_shift_2)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 472
Topic starter   [#29041]

I’ve been knee-deep in their platform for the last six months, trying to build reliable dashboards for our NOC. Here’s the thing: the example queries they provide in their community forums and docs feel like they were written in a vacuum. They look good in a demo but fall apart under real load or complex filtering.

Take the classic "top applications by bandwidth" example. It's plastered everywhere. But in practice, it lacks any notion of baselining or anomaly detection. It just gives you a static list. For a night shift engineer, I need to know what's *unexpected*. A simple top-N doesn't help when everything is just "high."

```promql
# Their common example – pretty, but not proactive
sum(rate(iboss_bandwidth_bytes[5m])) by (application)
topk(10, subquery)
```

Where’s the comparison to last week? Where’s the threshold that adapts to time of day? I end up rewriting every single one to incorporate delta functions and seasonality. It feels like the provided queries are designed to check a box, not to actually surface incidents.

Has anyone else found this? What snippets *have* you found genuinely useful, and what did you have to change to make them operational? I'm starting to think the real value isn't in their queries, but in the raw metric names—once you ignore their suggested use.

zzz


Sleep is for the weak


   
Quote
(@cloud_cost_breaker)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 591
 

You've hit on the core problem with vendor-provided queries: they're built for a clean, static environment, not for production's noise and variance.

That `topk` example is a classic vanity metric. To make it operational for alerting, we often replace it with a calculation of standard deviation from a rolling baseline. Here's a simplified version we run:

```promql
( avg_over_time(rate(iboss_bandwidth_bytes[5m])[1h:]) * 2 )
```

It's not perfect, but comparing the current 5m rate to the 1-hour rolling average (and flagging anything beyond 2 standard deviations) starts to show what's *unexpected* for that specific time period, not just generically high.

The useful snippets are usually the obscure ones about label manipulation or metric relabeling - the plumbing, not the dashboard candy.


Less spend, more headroom.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_cost_breaker)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 591
 

You're right about the lack of baselining. The static `topk` query is a diagnostic starting point, not an operational tool.

The genuinely useful snippets I've found are the ones for cost allocation, like Prometheus metric relabeling to map Kubernetes pods to a department or project. Even those need heavy modification to match our actual label schema. The vendor examples assume perfect, consistent labeling that rarely exists.

Your point about seasonality is key. For cloud costs, a simple weekly comparison is more actionable than a static top 10. I've had to build queries that compare current spend to the same day last week and apply a dynamic threshold, which the provided examples never touch.


Less spend, more headroom.


   
ReplyQuote
(@consultant_mark_2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 293
 

You're pointing out the core issue: vendor queries are often designed for a vendor's proof-of-value, not for your production runbook. The boilerplate examples serve as syntax tutorials, not operational logic.

The "comparison to last week" you mentioned is a perfect example. A useful template would include an `offset 7d` or a comparison function, but they don't. That introduces operational risk because an engineer has to design and validate the time-series logic themselves. I've seen teams waste weeks building that institutional knowledge.

The few genuinely useful snippets I've salvaged are always about data hygiene, like filtering out low-cardinality series that bloat queries. Even those require heavy modification. The truth is, these queries aren't for you; they're for the sales engineer's next demo.


independent eye


   
ReplyQuote