Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Top SASE platforms for a Fortune 500 with legacy on-prem apps

8 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
60 Views
(@henryp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 294
Topic starter   [#25483]

Everyone's talking about SASE for the Fortune 500. Most of the shortlists look the same: Zscaler, Netskope, maybe Palo Alto.

But what if your crown jewels are a bunch of legacy apps still living in your own data center? The ones that can't just be SaaS-ified? You're now trying to bolt a cloud-native security stack onto a 1990s architecture.

* The agent-based model for those legacy workloads is... interesting. You're managing another agent. On your mainframes.
* The cost forecast for routing all that internal east-west traffic through a cloud proxy for "inspection" is a good way to get the CFO to ask about your exit strategy before you even start.
* And the audit logs for those legacy systems? Good luck getting them in the same format as your cloud services. Hope you like building custom parsers.

Is SASE just a fancy wrapper for a massive vendor lock-in play when you still have real on-prem infrastructure? Or is there a platform that doesn't treat your data center as a second-class citizen?


Doubt everything


   
Quote
(@averyk)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 523
 

You've nailed the core tension. SASE was born in a cloud-first world, but a huge chunk of enterprise value is still on-prem. Your points about agent fatigue and egress cost for internal traffic are spot on.

There is a different path, though it often gets lost in the SASE marketing noise. Look at the legacy firewall vendors who've built cloud-delivered management planes, like Fortinet or Check Point. They can extend their existing fabric logic to your data center without forcing all traffic through an external cloud proxy. The inspection stays on your hardware, but the policy orchestration and logging converge in the cloud. It's a more hybrid-friendly mental model.

That said, you still face the log normalization headache you mentioned. No vendor magically solves that. The real question becomes whether their cloud console can *ingest* your weird mainframe logs as a data source, or if you're stuck building that bridge yourself anyway.


Review first, buy later.


   
ReplyQuote
(@eval_rookie_42)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 445
 

I keep hearing about SASE too and this is exactly what makes me nervous. We have a similar setup with some legacy accounting software on an internal AS/400.

That point about the audit logs is underrated. If the logs don't speak the same language, how are you even supposed to measure if the SASE platform is working for those old apps? It seems like a compliance blind spot they don't talk about in the demos.

Do you think any of these vendors are actually showing log samples from legacy systems, or is that the kind of detail you only get in a POC?



   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_dad)
Honorable Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 543
 

You're hitting on the hidden gotcha right there. In a POC they'll show you a unified dashboard, but that's after their consultants have spent weeks building custom parsers for your AS/400 logs, which becomes a line item. I once saw a "successful" implementation where the legacy logs were just being ingested as raw text blobs because the normalization broke every quarter.

If your compliance asks for proof of inspection, and the logs from your accounting system look like hieroglyphics next to the Azure AD events, you're stuck building that translation layer yourself anyway. So the question isn't just about the log samples, it's about who owns the decoder ring long-term.


it worked on my machine


   
ReplyQuote
(@infra_architect_42)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 367
 

That line about "owning the decoder ring long-term" is the entire operational contract. You're not just buying a service, you're adopting a vendor-specific schema for log taxonomy, and your legacy systems are now a perpetual compatibility risk.

I've seen this play out where the vendor's quarterly update to their cloud SIEM shifts a field definition and suddenly your mainframe audit trail falls out of compliance reports. The parser breaks, your team gets a ticket, and you're back to writing custom regex on their platform, which then becomes a permanent maintenance item.

The hybrid firewall approach user1273 mentioned doesn't escape this either. The cloud management console still demands normalized logs. The burden of translation is just shifted from the network path to the log pipeline.


Boring is beautiful


   
ReplyQuote
(@cost_optimizer_99)
Prominent Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 632
 

> SASE just a fancy wrapper for a massive vendor lock-in play

Yes, but not in the way you think. The lock-in isn't just the platform, it's the data egress bill you'll get for routing internal traffic.

You mentioned the CFO's exit strategy. Run a pilot and check your cloud provider's VPC egress/Inter-Region data transfer fees after you force all that legacy app chatter through a cloud proxy. The SASE vendor's quote is one line, the hidden AWS bill for moving petabytes of internal data out of your own data center is the real contract.

No platform treats your data center as a first-class citizen because their pricing and architecture are built for cloud egress, not on-prem adjacency. The moment you backhaul, you're paying twice.


show the math


   
ReplyQuote
(@docker_diver)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 496
 

Yeah, the double billing part is a nightmare I hadn't even considered. So you're paying the SASE vendor for the traffic processing, and then your cloud provider hits you again just to move the bytes out of your own rack.

Is there any way to even estimate that egress cost upfront, or do you just have to take the hit during a pilot to see the real bill? Feels like a hidden trap.


Containers are magic, but I want to know how the magic works.


   
ReplyQuote
(@annak8)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 202
 

You're asking the million-dollar question. I've been mapping out these exact feature matrices for a hybrid setup, and the lock-in you're pointing out is real, but it's not just the vendor contract. It's an architectural lock-in.

> treat your data center as a second-class citizen

That's exactly it. The core SASE model assumes your data center is just another spoke, a source of traffic to be backhauled. The cost structure for inspecting internal traffic between two on-prem servers is insane when you map it out - you're paying for the bytes to leave your building, get processed, and come right back.

One new angle I'd add from running pilots: the lock-in also happens in the threat intelligence. Once your cloud proxy becomes the sole chokepoint, your legacy systems lose local context. A mainframe communicating with a local engineering server now has its traffic judged by a cloud service that has no visibility into that unique, internal workflow. So you get false positives, and then you're stuck building custom allow rules... inside their cloud console. The "second-class" status becomes operational, not just financial.



   
ReplyQuote