You've already lost. If you have 500+ alerts on day one, your pipeline is broken and you're using the tool wrong. You're treating a security scanner like a magic wand instead of a precision instrument.
First, stop the bleeding. You need a baseline. Don't even look at the alerts yet. Create a policy file to suppress everything by severity and path. Start with all `low` and `medium` in legacy code (`vendor/`, `node_modules/`, `legacy-apps/`). Use the CodeQL query suite filter.
```yaml
# .github/codeql/codeql-config.yml
paths-ignore:
- vendor
- node_modules
- legacy-apps/**/*.js
- **/*.test.js
query-filters:
- exclude:
severity: low
precision: low
```
Now you have maybe 50 alerts. Sort by exploitability, not severity. Look for `high`/`critical` in authentication, file upload, or direct database query paths. Ignore theoretical vulnerabilities in internal admin panels with no external access. Triage is about risk, not checkbox compliance.
Don't panic, have a rollback plan.
I'm a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company, and we've been running Snyk and GitHub Advanced Security in our pipelines for about two years.
The core choice for us came down to GitHub Advanced Security vs a dedicated SAST tool like Snyk. Here's how they compared for our initial triage situation:
**Initial setup and baseline effort**: GitHub Advanced Security was easier to baseline because the path filters and query suites are configured in the same YAML files as your workflows. Snyk required us to manage a separate `.snyk` policy file, which added an extra step.
**Alert noise and precision**: For a 500-alert starting point, GitHub's default queries flagged many low-precision issues in test files. We had to manually add `**/*.test.js` to `paths-ignore`. Snyk's default policy was more aggressive at suppressing known low-severity patterns in third-party code out of the box.
**Cost model at scale**: GitHub Advanced Security costs by committer, roughly $21 per active committer/month. That got expensive fast for us with many developers. Snyk's pricing was based on the number of projects and scans, which we found easier to predict, around $25-35 per developer/month for the full platform.
**Integration depth for remediation**: Snyk clearly wins on providing actionable fixes. It generates PRs with dependency upgrades and often suggests code patches for SAST findings. GitHub's alerts point you to the line of code but usually leave the fix research to you.
I'd recommend starting with GitHub Advanced Security if you're already on GitHub and need a simple, integrated baseline fast. Go with Snyk if your main goal is reducing the fix burden for developers, even if it costs a bit more. To make a clean call, tell us your current primary repo host and whether your team has dedicated AppSec time or if developers are expected to fix their own alerts.
Your point about Snyk's pricing being based on projects/scans is valid for cost predictability, but it creates a different incentive. With GitHub's committer-based model, you're incentivized to get everyone using the tool, which can drive adoption. The per-project model can lead to teams avoiding new scans to control costs, which undermines the whole purpose.
On the noise comparison, I'd add that GitHub's query suite is actually more granular if you dig into the CodeQL packs. You can disable entire categories (like `js/security/missing-token-validation`) at the organizational level, not just by path. Snyk's out-of-the-box suppression is a time-saver initially, but it can mask issues you'd want to see later when you tighten policies.
numbers don't lie
Exactly, and that pricing incentive changes how you negotiate. With GitHub's seat-based model, you can often bundle it into an existing ELA. I've gotten it as a "free" add-on for a 20% commit increase on our overall Microsoft contract.
Snyk's per-project model is tougher to scale cost-effectively. You're right, teams will avoid adding repos. You need a hard rule in procurement that new projects *must* be scanned, otherwise your initial license buy is wasted.
The category-level suppression is a huge plus for long-term TCO. You can start broad and surgically re-enable queries as your team's skill improves, without drowning them.