Just wrapped up a proof of concept between Microsoft Defender for Endpoint and VMware Carbon Black. We're a mid-sized SaaS shop, and budget is always tight, so the decision basically made itself on cost. MDE was significantly cheaper for us, especially with our existing Microsoft 365 licensing.
But man, the user experience feels like a step back. The portal is clunky compared to Carbon Black's. I found it harder to get a quick, clear overview of our endpoint security posture. Triage and investigation workflows felt slower. Anyone else have this experience? Is the UX something you just get used to, or are there tricks to make it feel smoother? The price is right, but I'm worried about our team actually using it effectively day-to-day.
You've absolutely nailed the initial experience. That "step back" feeling is real, especially coming from a purpose-built EDR console. The trick, I've found, is to stop treating the Microsoft 365 Defender portal as a single pane of glass and instead build your own glass.
For us, the triage speed only improved when we gave up on the portal for daily overviews. We built a Power BI dashboard that pulls directly from the advanced hunting tables via API. It's not trivial, but it gives us the clean, at-a-glance view we needed. For investigation, learning the Kusto query language for advanced hunting is non-negotiable; it's the only way to make the raw data work at the speed you're used to.
The irony is that while Carbon Black's UX is smoother out of the box, MDE's data model is actually more open. You're paying less up front but investing more in internal tooling to make it sing. Did your POC include any time to explore the APIs and data export options?
api first
Your point about the cost making the decision is spot on. The licensing bundling is almost impossible to beat for shops already on Microsoft 365.
On the UX, you do get somewhat used to it, but I wouldn't call it smooth. The real shift is accepting the portal as a data source rather than a finished dashboard. The quick overview you're missing won't materialize on its own. You'll need to build custom views for your team's specific triage metrics, either through pinned advanced hunting queries or pulling data out to a separate reporting tool. It's an initial time investment the cheaper licensing effectively pays for.
Your bill is too high.
Totally get that initial clunky feeling. We made the same switch last year. The overview page is basically useless for us too.
What helped was creating a set of bookmarks for the specific advanced hunting queries we run every morning. It bypasses the dashboard entirely. Takes a week to build the habit, but after that, the portal just becomes a launchpad for those queries.
And honestly, the worst part for us was the alert fatigue at first. The default tuning is... aggressive. Once we dialed that in, the noise dropped and the triage got a bit faster. Still miss the polish of a dedicated tool though.