Hey everyone! 👋 I'm deep in the evaluation phase for a Zero Trust solution and we've got Banyan Security lined up for a proof of concept. Super excited to see it in action, but I've been burned before by PoCs that looked great in the demo but fell apart when we tried to fit them into our actual workflows.
For those of you who've been through this with Banyan or similar tools, what were the red flags you wish you'd spotted earlier? I'm especially thinking about things that aren't obvious in a sales presentation.
From my own corner in marketing automation, I'm already watching for:
* How clunky the admin experience gets when scaling policies for different teams (we have dev, marketing, and customer support needing very different access).
* The true effort required to integrate with our existing identity provider and HR system for automated onboarding/offboarding. The "it's just a few clicks" claim makes me nervous!
* Real-world performance impact on the end-user experience. Does it slow down app access noticeably?
Would love to hear your war storiesβwhat snagged you during the PoC? Was it the reporting, the unexpected config complexity, or something about the agent behavior? Happy building!
You're already watching the right things, especially the "just a few clicks" integration claim. That's usually where the real cost gets buried.
Biggest red flag is when the pre-sales engineer vanishes and you're handed off to generic support for the PoC setup. If they can't match your actual identity provider config during the trial, they never will.
Also, test the policy changes yourself. The demo will show a slick flow for marketing. Try building one for devs and see how many nested menus it takes. That's where the admin burden really hits six months in. Good luck.
CRM is a means, not an end.
You're already thinking about the right things. I'd push a bit on that "true effort to integrate" point. We had a similar situation where the pre-sales script worked with a fresh Okta test tenant, but our production setup had a few custom claims. The PoC glossed over it, saying it was "supported." It wasn't, and we spent three weeks post-purchase writing a Lambda function to bridge the gap.
My red flag is actually around the agent behavior during the PoC. Ask them to simulate a network blip or a policy update *while someone is actively using an app*. Does the session just freeze, or does it fail gracefully? That's where you see if their zero-trust logic holds up under real-world hiccups.
Clean code is not an option, it's a sanity measure.
The "real-world performance impact" question is the right one. Sales demos always show the app launching instantly over a pristine connection. You need to see what happens with your actual network, which probably has packet loss and jitter.
Set up a test where you deliberately degrade the link between the agent and their gateway, then have someone try to use an internal tool like Jira or GitLab. If sessions just hang instead of reconnecting cleanly, you've found a fundamental protocol flaw they won't fix.
And while you're testing the agent, try installing it on the exact OS image your company actually uses, not the fresh VM they provide. That's where you'll find the hidden dependency on a specific OpenSSL version or a kernel module that's blacklisted by your security team.
null
The onboarding/offboarding automation is where most promises break. The "few clicks" claim often assumes a pristine, default IdP setup.
Test it by simulating a real termination: disable the user's AD/LDAP account and revoke their session tokens. See if their access is truly killed immediately or if there's a cache or delay. If their agent can still reach Jira for 15 minutes, that's a critical fail.
Your point about performance is key, but test it under load. Spin up 50 concurrent connections to a heavy internal app and watch resource usage on the gateway VM. If CPU spikes and latency jumps, their scaling story is weak.
Trust but verify, then don't trust.