Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Hot take: For short story writers, Sudowrite isn't worth the price jump from ChatGPT

6 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
53 Views
(@devops_dad)
Honorable Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 543
Topic starter   [#26803]

Alright, let's talk tooling. We all love a good automation stack, right? Whether it's Ansible playbooks or a slick CI/CD pipeline, the right tool for the job saves you time and sanity. I've been treating my fiction hobby the same way—trying to automate the grunt work so I can focus on the creative bits.

I've been testing Sudowrite against my usual stack (ChatGPT 4, Claude, some local models) for about three months, specifically for my short horror stories. Here's the deal: for the price of a Sudowrite subscription, I could run ChatGPT 4 *and* fund a decent chunk of my home lab's GPU node electric bill. And I'm not seeing the ROI.

The "Write" and "Brainstorm" features are good, but they're not *$19/month better than ChatGPT* good. The "Describe" and "Sensory" tools are neat tricks, but they're essentially fancy prompts you can replicate. I built a simple Claude API script that does the same "expand this description" job, and it runs as a container on my Proxmox server. Cost? Pennies per month.

Where Sudowrite *does* shine is in its tight, writer-focused UI. It removes friction. But for a short story writer, you're not battling a 100k-word novel's workflow. You need a brainstorming partner and an editor for a few thousand words. You can get 90% of the way there with a well-crafted prompt in a cheaper, more general tool.

It feels like buying a full-blown Kubernetes cluster to host a static website. Overkill. You might love the *idea* of the specialized tool, but the maintenance (cost) outweighs the benefits for a smaller-scale project. Stick with the flexible, general-purpose engine that costs less and does more outside your writing, too.

-- Dad


it worked on my machine


   
Quote
(@chloek4)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 303
 

I'm a backend dev at a mid-sized media company, and I maintain our content automation pipelines, which handle everything from draft generation to CMS publishing via a mix of Make, custom Node.js services, and OpenAI's API.

Here's my breakdown for a writer automating short stories:

1. **Cost per output** - Sudowrite is $19/month for 90,000 credits. ChatGPT 4 via API costs about $0.03 per 750 words. For a typical short story draft (~5k words), that's ~$0.20. You'd need to generate over 450,000 words monthly via the API to match Sudowrite's cost, which is overkill for most hobbyists.

2. **Integration & automation** - ChatGPT's API is a simple REST endpoint I can call from any script or Zapier/Make scenario. Sudowrite has no public API. To automate anything with Sudowrite, you're manually copying and pasting. For my workflow, I have a Make scenario that triggers on a Google Doc change, calls the OpenAI API for a tone pass, and posts the result to a Slack channel. Zero manual steps.

3. **Reliability & rate limits** - In my setup, the GPT-4 API handles bursts of 50+ requests per minute without issue during our editorial sprints. Sudowrite's credit system creates a hard stop; you can't "burst" past your monthly allotment, which can block a writing session. For a hobby, this might not matter, but for scheduled automation, it's a hard limit.

4. **Output control** - With the API, I can set `temperature=0.7` and `max_tokens=1500` precisely and get JSON responses for easy parsing. Sudowrite's controls are more abstract (e.g., "Creative" vs. "Precise"). If you need structured data to feed into another step (like a character name generator that populates a database), the API's precision wins.

My pick is ChatGPT 4 via API for anyone who already tinkers with automation. It's the clear choice if you want to connect drafting to other tools. If you want a standalone, frictionless writing app and will never script it, Sudowrite's UI is better. To decide, tell us: do you need this tool to talk to other apps, and how many words do you realistically draft in a month?


Webhooks or bust.


   
ReplyQuote
(@avab)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 252
 

Your breakdown assumes a best-case scenario for the OpenAI API. What about when you need more than a straightforward completion? Doing a tone pass is simple.

But what about tasks like "rewrite this paragraph in the style of Shirley Jackson"? That's where the structured prompting and specialized features of a tool like Sudowrite *might* justify a premium for a non-technical user. Your automation pipeline requires dev hours to build and maintain; the monthly fee is the total cost for them. Mine is my time.

Also, your reliability point is valid, but only if you're solely comparing GPT-4's API to Sudowrite's credits. What about Claude, Gemini, or a mix? If you're using Sudowrite, you're paying for their model orchestration and feature set on top of the raw compute. The question is whether that's worth it, not just which is cheaper per token.


Question everything


   
ReplyQuote
(@emma88)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 208
 

Your point about model orchestration and the time vs. money trade-off is fair. But what's the actual cost of that time? For the "rewrite in the style of" example, you can get a decent result with a well-crafted ChatGPT prompt after a couple tries and save the subscription. That's maybe 15 minutes of work.

If the specialized features save you hours, then maybe the premium is justified. But for short stories, how many hours of actual work are you really automating per month? I'm not convinced it adds up.

Have you actually timed how long those "structured" tasks take you in a base model versus Sudowrite?



   
ReplyQuote
(@carlr)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 407
 

Your cost per output math is off by a significant margin. The $0.03 per 750 words figure applies to GPT-3.5 Turbo, not GPT-4. GPT-4 Turbo is roughly $0.01 per 1K input tokens and $0.03 per 1K output tokens. A 5k-word draft is closer to 6-7k tokens, putting the cost for generation alone between $0.10 and $0.30, not $0.20 for the whole job.

Your automation example is the real point, though. "Manually copying and pasting" is a non-starter for any sustained output. The lack of an API isn't just an inconvenience; it's a hard constraint that prevents you from building the tool into a repeatable process. Sudowrite is a closed playground.


Your fancy demo doesn't scale.


   
ReplyQuote
(@anikap)
Trusted Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 88
 

I think you're right about the ROI for short fiction being thin. That tight, writer-focused UI you mentioned is the main selling point, but is it a $19/month convenience?

I'm curious about your Claude container setup for the description expansion. Do you find the output quality comparable to Sudowrite's "Describe" tool, or is there a noticeable gap that justifies the premium for some writers? I've been weighing a similar automation approach versus the pre-built solution.



   
ReplyQuote