Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Comparison: Using Kimi for meeting notes vs. Otter.ai vs. Fireflies.ai.

5 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
70 Views
(@alexc)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 341
Topic starter   [#23790]

Just tried using Kimi to transcribe a team sync. I usually bounce between Otter.ai and Fireflies, so I ran the same meeting through all three to compare.

Kimi's accuracy was solid for English, maybe 5% more errors than Otter on technical terms. The big difference is the context window – I could paste the transcript and ask "extract action items for the backend team" and it worked. Otter's summaries are more rigid. Fireflies still wins on CRM integrations, but Kimi feels more like an analysis tool than just a recorder.

Cost-wise, Kimi's a no-brainer if you're already using it for other tasks. For a dedicated meeting bot, Fireflies is more automated. Still testing, but Kimi is surprisingly capable as a free option.

Anyone else tried this? Curious about handling accented speakers or very fast talkers.


Automate everything.


   
Quote
(@benjislack)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 244
 

I run a 50-person dev shop on Slack/Jira/Google Workspace. We've trialed all three for our daily standups and client calls.

1. **Target Audience:** Otter and Fireflies are built for meeting-specific workflows. Kimi is a generalist AI with a meeting feature bolted on. If meetings are your primary use, the dedicated tools have a clear edge.
2. **Real Pricing:** Otter's business plan is $20/user/month. Fireflies starts at $18/user/month for decent automation. Kimi's current free tier is a loophole, not a business model. Assume it will monetize or restrict usage heavily.
3. **Integration Effort:** Fireflies wins if you live in Salesforce or HubSpot. Otter integrates with Zoom/Teams calendars cleanly. Getting Kimi's output into a task tracker requires manual paste or a DIY script.
4. **Where It Breaks:** Kimi's transcription falls apart with heavy accents and crosstalk in my tests. Otter's speaker diarization is more consistent. Fireflies can miss context when summarizing dense technical debates.

For a dedicated, set-and-forget meeting bot, I'd pick Fireflies. If you need a free, manual analysis tool for occasional meetings and are willing to correct transcripts, Kimi works. Tell us your meeting volume per week and whether you need automatic CRM updates.


your mileage will vary


   
ReplyQuote
(@chrisw2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 309
 

I've used Kimi for a couple of post-mortem calls. Your point about it being an analysis tool nails it.

On accented speakers, I did a test with a colleague from Glasgow. Kimi and Otter both stumbled a bit, but Otter's speaker diarization was better at separating the voices when the accent was thick. For very fast talkers, you can drop the audio file into Kimi and it handles it, but the real-time aspect isn't there like with Fireflies.

The free tier is the main draw, but you're stuck with manual uploads. If I'm already in a meeting, I'd rather have Fireflies auto-join and log the ticket for me. Kimi's for when you need to interrogate the transcript after the fact.


Run it yourself.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_cost_optimizer)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 473
 

Your point about Kimi's free tier being a loophole is critical for long-term planning. We evaluated it under the same assumption and modeled three scenarios: Kimi remains free, introduces a $10/user/month tier, or restricts to 10 hours monthly. Only the free scenario made it cost-competitive with dedicated tools when you factor in the manual labor for uploads and integration.

Your integration effort breakdown aligns with our findings. For a shop your size on Jira, the "DIY script" to push action items isn't trivial. We built a connector using their API and a Lambda function, but the ongoing maintenance overhead adds roughly 15% to the effective cost compared to a native integration.


every dollar counts


   
ReplyQuote
(@aubreyk)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 90
 

That's a good point about Kimi being for interrogation after the fact. I was hoping to use it for real-time support calls to pull out customer pain points, but the manual upload kills the workflow.

Is the speaker diarization you mentioned a paid Otter feature, or is it on their free plan too? I'm trying to gauge the real starting cost.



   
ReplyQuote