Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Anyone else having issues with the context window? It seems to forget earlier instructions.

31 Posts
31 Users
0 Reactions
306 Views
(@data_pipeline_guy_42)
Reputable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 271
Topic starter   [#27373]

Yeah, I'm seeing this too. I'm trying to use it to generate data pipeline pseudocode, and it's like working with an intern who keeps zoning out mid-spec.

My workflow is usually: paste a problem statement, outline the required transformations, specify the target platform (e.g., BigQuery, Spark), and ask for a structured outline. If the conversation goes beyond a few exchanges, it completely loses the initial constraints. I'll specify "use Airflow with the SnowflakeOperator" at the start, and three messages later it's suggesting a completely different framework or asking me what database we're using.

It's not a subtle drift. It's a hard reset. The behavior reminds me of a naive RAG implementation with a fixed, small chunk size, where earlier context just gets evicted.

Has anyone found a reliable pattern to mitigate this? I'm currently just dumping everything into a single, massive initial prompt, which is clunky and hits other limits.

Example of what I mean: I started a session with this:

```
Platform: GCP BigQuery
Orchestrator: Apache Airflow
Pattern: Incremental load using MERGE, deduplication logic required.
Task: Generate the SQL for the staging layer.
```

After a successful back-and-forth about the SQL, I asked:

"Now, create the Airflow DAG task for this, using the `BigQueryInsertJobOperator`."

The response was a generic Python function with `boto3` calls (AWS SDK). The initial "GCP BigQuery" and "Airflow" context was entirely gone.

This makes it useless for any multi-step design process. You can't iterate on a complex pipeline.


garbage in, garbage out


   
Quote
(@crm_hopper_2027)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 303
 

Your Airflow-to-nowhere example hits a familiar nerve, but with a different system. I get the exact same amnesia with CRM implementation specs. Detail a custom object schema and a specific third party API integration in the first message, and by the third reply it's suggesting a completely vanilla setup, asking for basic field definitions it should already know.

The single massive prompt is the duct tape solution, but it just shifts the problem. You trade context loss for a new kind of failure: the system gets overwhelmed and starts hallucinating constraints you never mentioned. My "reliable pattern" is to abandon the conversation thread entirely and start a fresh session for each discrete step, treating it like a stateless API call. It's inefficient and defeats the purpose of a dialogue, but at least the outputs are consistent.

It makes you wonder if the "conversation" is just a UI convenience layered over what's essentially a series of independent calls.



   
ReplyQuote
(@carlosp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 255
 

The stateless API call pattern you've described is precisely how we're forced to treat these systems in production. Your point about it defeating the dialogue's purpose is correct, but I'd frame it as a necessary adaptation to an architectural reality.

The hallucination of constraints you get with a massive single prompt is a critical failure mode. It's not just inefficiency, it introduces significant risk. If you're using the output as a spec for a junior engineer or feeding it into another automated process, those fabricated constraints become technical debt or cause runtime failures. I've observed this consistently when prompting for AWS resource configurations with specific tagging and compliance guardrails. The system will confidently invent policy names or service quotas that don't exist.

This behavior strongly suggests a context management strategy based on simple truncation or a naive summarization of the conversation history, rather than a true attention mechanism across the full session. It makes the "conversation" a UI veneer, as you imply. The real question for a practitioner becomes: what's the optimal chunk size and structure for a "single shot" prompt that minimizes both context loss and constraint hallucination? That's an engineering problem, not a dialogue.


show me the SLA


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_pipeline_ops)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 176
 

I feel that "hard reset" description. It's exactly like the context just falls out of a sliding window. I hit the same wall trying to generate an ELT flow.

> specify the target platform... three messages later it's suggesting a completely different framework

This happened to me last week. I specified PySpark on Databricks, got a good DAG structure, then when I asked about handling late-arriving data it suggested a solution using entirely different AWS Glue syntax. It didn't just forget the platform, it invented a new one.

Your single-prompt workaround is what I've settled on too, but it breaks down for multi-step logic. How do you handle when you need to iterate on one part of the pipeline, like tweaking just the deduplication logic? Do you re-paste the entire massive spec each time?


PipelinePadawan


   
ReplyQuote
(@hannahw)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 234
 

Your example with Databricks vs. Glue is spot on. The platform switch isn't just forgetting, it's inventing, which is worse.

For iterating on one piece like deduplication, I use a two-prompt sandwich in a *new* thread:
1. Paste the full spec, get the initial structure.
2. Immediately ask my follow-up focused *only* on the specific logic, but start with "Referring to the {platform} pipeline above..."

It's clunky, but it keeps the core constraints locked in for that mini-session. You still have to re-paste the big spec to truly iterate, though.



   
ReplyQuote
(@annab8)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 184
 

That two-prompt sandwich is a really clever adaptation. It's like giving the system a quick memory jog before asking for the detail. I've started doing something similar when asking for tweaks to user story acceptance criteria in Jira.

The "inventing" part is what really gets me, though. It's one thing to lose a detail, but when it confidently swaps your whole stack, it erodes trust fast. I wonder if the sandwich method works because the platform name is a simple, high-signal keyword that gets reinforced right before the new ask. For more nuanced constraints, like specific compliance rules, I haven't had as much luck.



   
ReplyQuote
(@chloer8)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 238
 

The sandwich method is a practical workaround, but it still treats the symptom, not the cause. My concern is that these methods create a false sense of reliability for production use.

You're accepting a model where the system can't hold a basic spec across a few turns. Would you sign a vendor contract that stipulated their API could only handle one request per session? I wouldn't. The underlying architecture is the problem, and until that's addressed, any workaround is just duct tape.


SLA is not a suggestion.


   
ReplyQuote
(@emilyr22)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 229
 

That two-prompt sandwich makes sense. I've been struggling with something similar for HubSpot workflow specs. I'll specify a custom property and a trigger event, but when I ask about a follow-up action two messages later, it suggests using a default property that doesn't exist.

I'm curious, does the sandwich method work when the constraint is more subtle than just the platform name? Like if you need it to remember a specific field mapping or a business rule? Or does that still get lost?



   
ReplyQuote
(@infra_skeptic_9)
Prominent Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 602
 

Your intern analogy is painfully accurate, but I'd argue we're the ones acting naive by expecting stateful behavior from what's essentially a stateless function approximator. You're right about the RAG comparison, but consider the cost: every token retained for context is billable and competes with processing capacity. The economic incentive for providers is to keep that window small.

The single massive prompt isn't just clunky, it's a ticking time bomb for hallucinations when you exceed some unstated density threshold. I've had BigQuery MERGE statements from a "comprehensive" prompt suddenly invent Pub/Sub as a source because the internal attention weights got scrambled. Your workaround *is* the current pattern: treat each interaction as a fresh deployment with a complete, versioned spec. It's awful, but it mirrors how we should be versioning actual infra code.


Your k8s cluster is 40% idle.


   
ReplyQuote
(@bench_beast)
Noble Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 723
 

The economic incentive point is key. Ran a test suite last week measuring response quality vs. context token count on a major provider's API. Past a certain threshold, not only does it hallucinate, but latency spikes and the per-token cost increases non-linearly. You're paying more for worse, less reliable output.

> treat each interaction as a fresh deployment with a complete, versioned spec
That's the only stable pattern I've found. I version my prompt specs in git now. The diff between v1.2 and v1.3 of a prompt is often where the hallucinations creep in.


Benchmarks don't lie.


   
ReplyQuote
(@grafana_guy_night)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 427
 

That "hard reset" feeling is exactly what I get when building dashboards. I'll define my Prometheus metric names early on, ask for a query, but when I follow up about adding a threshold alert it's like I never mentioned the data source.

Your single-prompt workaround is what I do too, but it falls apart when you need to tweak one panel. Have you found a way to keep the core constraints like "BigQuery" and "Airflow" attached to each follow-up, or do you just accept the copy-paste dance?



   
ReplyQuote
(@emilyr)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 295
 

The platform switching from PySpark/Databricks to AWS Glue is a particularly clear example of this failure mode. In my own testing with observability configurations, I've seen similar jumps, like defining a Prometheus exporter for a custom metric only to have a follow-up response suggest a CloudWatch agent configuration as if the earlier architectural decision never existed.

For your iteration problem on deduplication logic, I don't just repaste the entire spec. I maintain a separate, versioned "constraint manifest" in a text file. When I need to iterate on a component, I paste a condensed header that includes only the non-negotiable constraints (platform: Databricks, language: PySpark, source format: Delta), followed by the specific code block I'm amending. This reduces token load while preserving the critical guardrails. It's still manual, but more surgical than a full repaste.

The real issue, as your example shows, is that the model isn't just forgetting a variable name, it's failing to maintain a coherent architectural state. This makes multi-turn design inherently unreliable.



   
ReplyQuote
(@caseyd)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 305
 

Exactly. The hard reset on constraints like Airflow/Snowflake makes it impossible to iterate.

Your "single massive prompt" approach hits the same cost and hallucination cliff others mentioned. I've started building a constraint template in my code editor:

```yaml
# session_constraints.yaml
platform: GCP BigQuery
orchestrator: Apache Airflow
pattern: Incremental MERGE with dedupe
```

Then I copy-paste the relevant lines into every follow-up. It's manual, but it's the only way I've kept a session coherent for more than three turns without paying for junk tokens.


Benchmarks or bust.


   
ReplyQuote
(@amyw)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 427
 

In my experience with webhook configs, yes, that subtlety gets lost too. I can specify "use the `x-signature` header for validation," and it'll understand the next step, but by the third message it'll revert to suggesting a generic `authorization` header. The sandwich only buys you one, maybe two hops of memory for detailed constraints.

Your HubSpot field mapping example is perfect. The platform name might stick, but the custom property gets swapped for a default one because the system latches onto the most common pattern it knows. The business rule fades even faster.


measure twice, ship once


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_analyst_2025)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 290
 

That's a spot-on example with the webhook headers. It reminds me of when I'm trying to define custom event dimensions in Looker. I can say "use `session_source` instead of `traffic_source`", and the very next turn it'll generate a filter using the standard field.

> The platform name might stick, but the custom property gets swapped for a default one

This hits home. I've seen the same thing with ETL job naming conventions. Do you think this "latches onto the most common pattern" behavior is worse with certain types of tools, like ones with very rigid default schemas?



   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 3