We recently deployed Elicit within our academic research lab (10 users, primarily postdocs and PhDs) to assist with systematic literature reviews and paper discovery. Our primary goal was to streamline the initial research phase, but a critical requirement was ensuring the findings could be seamlessly integrated into our existing knowledge bases in Notion (for collaborative projects) and Obsidian (for individual, linked notes).
The initial setup was straightforward via the web interface, but our security and compliance posture required addressing several points before full adoption:
* **Data Residency & Processing:** We needed clarity on where the uploaded papers (PDFs) and generated summaries/queries are processed and stored. The documentation mentions AWS, but the specific regions and any data sovereignty commitments for academic data were not immediately apparent.
* **Authentication & Access Control:** We are using the lab's Google Workspace. While OAuth integration exists, I am reviewing the permission scopes requested by Elicit. Furthermore, we require clear audit trails of which lab member performed which queries or uploaded which documents, especially for funded projects.
* **Data Encryption:** Understanding the encryption state for data at rest and in transit is fundamental. Are all user-uploaded documents and Elicit's outputs encrypted using platform-managed keys, or are customer-managed keys (CMK) an option?
* **Integration Security:** The Notion and Obsidian integrations operate via API tokens. The security model for these connections—token storage, refresh mechanisms, and the principle of least privilege for what Elicit can write to these systems—was a key part of our evaluation.
From a workflow perspective, the ability to push synthesized results directly into a structured Notion database has been valuable for group projects. For individual researchers, the one-click "Save to Obsidian" function preserves the AI-generated summaries and source links within their personal vaults, maintaining a local copy.
However, we encountered a significant pitfall regarding consistency. When multiple lab members ran similar or identical queries at different times, the result sets and even the summaries for the same paper sometimes varied. This raises questions about the deterministic nature of the underlying models and how it impacts reproducible research workflows.
I am seeking feedback from other institutional users, particularly in regulated or academic environments:
* How have you navigated the data governance questions, especially concerning proprietary or sensitive research drafts?
* Are there any specific compliance frameworks (like SOC 2 Type II) that Elicit has publicly articulated, which would simplify our security assessment?
* Has anyone built a more controlled pipeline, perhaps using Elicit's API with a middleware layer, to enforce stricter audit logging or data handling policies before results reach Notion/Obsidian?
Security is a feature, not an afterthought.
Oh, those are really good points. I hadn't even thought about > specific regions and any data sovereignty commitments for academic data. That's a big deal with some of the grants my lab handles too.
How did you get clarity on the data residency? Did you have to contact support, or was there a policy doc somewhere I'm missing? I'm looking at doing something similar.
CloudNewbie
>where the uploaded papers (PDFs) and generated summaries/queries are processed and stored
This is the exact hurdle we hit last year! We ended up reaching out to their support team directly. They were pretty responsive and sent over a detailed data processing agreement that outlined the AWS regions (US-East-1 was the primary one for us at the time). It wasn't front-and-center in the docs.
For audit trails, that was trickier. The user-level activity logging felt more built for individual accounts, not a shared lab context. We used a separate CI step in our workflow to tag exports with the user's Google ID before pushing to Notion. Not ideal, but it worked as a stopgap.
PipelinePerf
Oh, contacting support directly for the data agreement is a smart move. I wouldn't have thought of that.
>For audit trails, that was trickier.
The CI step workaround is interesting. Makes sense, but feels like you're building your own audit system outside the tool. Was setting up that CI step a big lift, or was it mostly just tagging metadata? I'm still learning that stuff.
They're right, it's building an audit system outside the tool. That's the whole problem.
The CI step itself wasn't complex if you're already automating exports. It was a simple metadata tag. The real lift was the policy and accountability design it forced us to create. Who checks the logs? How do we handle a mismatch? That's the hidden compliance tax.
If you're still learning CI, this isn't the place to start. You need the core workflow solid first, or you'll just automate a mess.