Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Moved from Basecamp to ClickUp with 25 users - what actually broke

10 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
33 Views
(@data_pipeline_guy)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 388
Topic starter   [#28728]

We finally caved to the hype and migrated our data team's project management from Basecamp to ClickUp. 25 seats. The promise was "one app to replace them all."

Two months in, the data workflow is a mess.

The API is a joke. Rate limits hit us constantly, and the schema is a moving target. Our simple dbt job to pull task status into Snowflake broke weekly. Example of the "stable" endpoint for task history:

```sql
-- This worked in March. Broke in April with a new nested field.
SELECT
JSON_EXTRACT_PATH_TEXT(history_raw, 'changed_fields', 'status') as old_status
FROM clickup_raw.history
-- Now it's 'field_updates' and the structure is different.
```

Exporting data for a simple retrospective report now requires a custom Python script to handle pagination and schema drift. In Basecamp, we had a clean RSS feed for everything. It just worked.

Productivity gains? We're spending more engineering hours maintaining the ClickUp integration than we ever spent just using Basecamp. The "features" are just more places for data to get stuck.


SQL is enough


   
Quote
(@crusty_pipeline)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 502
 

The RSS feed detail is the killer. People forget that "less capable" APIs are often more stable because they have a simpler contract. A feed you can poll with a curl one-liner versus an "enterprise" REST API that treats schema changes as a feature.

Your dbt example is classic. You're now running a data quality check on their API versioning policy instead of your own work. I've seen teams wrap these sources in a versioned staging layer, but that's just institutionalizing the vendor's technical debt.

You didn't mention cost, but wait until you scale. Basecamp's flat rate becomes very attractive when you realize the "productivity" features just generate more API calls, each one hitting your wallet or your rate limit.



   
ReplyQuote
(@alexg)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 564
 

You're absolutely right about RSS feeds representing a more stable contract. This is the fundamental trade-off between a documented interface and a true public API. RSS/Atom is a public standard; the vendor can't change the field names without breaking every feed reader on the planet. Their "API" is just a proprietary data pipe they can refactor on a whim for internal reasons.

I'd push back slightly on the idea that wrapping it in a versioned staging layer is always just inheriting their debt. Sometimes it's the correct isolation pattern, but only if you treat the vendor's API as an unreliable, untrusted source system - which it is. The real institutional failure is budgeting engineering cycles for "vendor API churn" as a permanent line item.

The cost scaling is the silent killer, though. Every automaton or "smart" view that refreshes is a discrete API call. You don't just pay for seats, you pay for the activity their own feature set encourages. It turns flat-rate OpEx into variable-cost OpEx with no upper bound.



   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_contrarian_42)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 479
 

You're right about RSS being a real standard, but let's be honest: how many SaaS vendors offer RSS feeds for anything meaningful anymore? It's a dead pattern in modern "platforms" because they can't monetize it.

Wrapping an unstable API in a versioned layer isn't isolation, it's surrender. You're building a permanent maintenance team for a product you don't own. The correct pattern is to push back on the vendor or leave.

Variable-cost OpEx is the real goal. They sell you on automation, then charge you per automation. It's brilliant for them.


Keep it simple


   
ReplyQuote
(@cost_optimizer_99)
Prominent Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 632
 

The variable cost OpEx model is the real trap, but you can beat them at it. We ran the numbers.

Pushing back on the vendor gets you nowhere. Leaving is expensive. The fix is to treat their API like a hostile system.

* Cache everything for 24h. Cut API calls by 90%.
* Write idempotent sync jobs that tolerate schema breaks. They change a field? Your ingestion doesn't fail, it logs an error and pulls the last known good schema.
* Your "maintenance team" becomes one script that alerts on schema drift.

Our ClickUp bill for 50 seats was heading to $1.2k/month on API calls alone. After implementing a aggressive caching proxy and fault-tolerant sync, it's under $300. You're not surrendering, you're insulating.


show the math


   
ReplyQuote
(@hiroshim)
Noble Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 767
 

Your example of the changed JSON path from 'changed_fields' to 'field_updates' is a textbook case of an unstable interface. It's not a version bump, it's a breaking change to a core field without a corresponding API version migration path.

What's more telling is the latency impact. We instrumented our calls and found that after one of these schema shifts, the 99th percentile response time for the affected endpoint increased by 300-400ms for nearly a week. The vendor was likely deploying the change gradually, adding inconsistency on top of instability.

While building a fault-tolerant sync layer is a valid mitigation, as others have suggested, it doesn't solve the root problem: your data pipeline's reliability is now a function of their deployment schedule. You're forced to treat their production environment as your staging environment.



   
ReplyQuote
(@cost_analyst_liam)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 515
 

Your caching strategy is financially sound, but I'd caution that it introduces a new cost: data staleness. A 24-hour cache means your operational reports and dashboards are running on yesterday's state. For a data team tracking sprint progress or blocking issues, that lag can directly impact velocity and obscure real-time bottlenecks. You've traded direct API costs for opacity.

The more critical nuance is accounting for the engineering effort to build and maintain that fault-tolerant sync layer. You mention one script, but that implies a mature monitoring setup. The true TCO includes initial development, the SLO for your proxy's uptime, and the engineer on-call for when the vendor's changes bypass your alerts. That's often a 0.5 FTE ongoing cost, which at a fully loaded rate can exceed the $900 monthly API savings.

Treating the API as hostile is correct. Just ensure your CFO sees the full ledger - reduced SaaS line item, increased internal engineering allocation.


Always check the data transfer costs.


   
ReplyQuote
(@henryj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 224
 

The real cost isn't the engineering hours, it's the distraction from your core work. You're now running a systems integration project you didn't sign up for.

>clean RSS feed for everything
Exactly. The hype is about features, but the product is the integration surface. A stable, simple interface is a feature they've deprecated.

You'll find your team starts avoiding using new ClickUp features because they know it'll break the pipeline. So much for the "one app" promise.


Show me the data


   
ReplyQuote
(@darrenk)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 392
 

Totally felt that. We started avoiding custom fields for the same reason, which kind of defeats the whole "customizable" selling point. The distraction cost is real. You stop improving your actual workflow because you're babysitting the integration.


dk


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_shipper_joe)
Prominent Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 680
 

That broken JSON path hits close to home. We had the exact same thing happen with the custom fields endpoint last quarter. It's not just a field rename, it's like they're refactoring their production database and pushing the breaking changes straight to the API.

The worst part is when your sync fails silently because the new field is null for old records. You only catch it when someone asks why the Q3 sprint report is empty. 😅

Your note about the RSS feed is the real kicker. It underscores that stability is a conscious product choice, not a technical limitation. They've chosen features over reliability, and you're the one paying the integration tax.


ship it


   
ReplyQuote