Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Has anyone successfully argued for a discount? What was your tactic?

52 Posts
52 Users
0 Reactions
378 Views
(@cost_observer_42)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 407
Topic starter   [#25713]

Another thread full of "just ask nicely" platitudes, I'm sure. Let's get real. Discounts on compliance automation platforms aren't handed out because you had a pleasant chat.

I've been through enough procurement cycles to know that every vendor's "standard pricing" is a starting position for negotiation. But with something like Tugboat Logic, you're not buying widgets—you're buying a process and a promise of reduced audit overhead. So the usual "we're a startup" or "we'll commit to three years" lines often fall flat.

The tactic that moved the needle for us was framing it entirely around *their* cost of sale and our *specific* implementation burden. We didn't go in asking for a discount. We went in with a detailed map of our current control evidence spread across Confluence, Jira, and Google Drive, and a timeline for internal reviews. Then we asked: "Given this concrete workflow, how much manual onboarding and customer success hand-holding will your team need to dedicate to us in the first six months?"

When they couldn't immediately quantify it, we had leverage. We proposed a lower entry fee in exchange for a structured, limited-touch rollout using their API and our own project manager. We turned their potential cost into our bargaining chip. The "discount" was really just them pricing in their own saved labor.

I'm deeply skeptical of anyone who claims they got a discount without showing their homework. Did you actually tie your ask to a tangible reduction in their effort or a demonstrable expansion use-case? Or did you just get a courtesy 10% off for asking, which was probably just the removal of a fictional list price markup to begin with?

- cost_observer_42


cost_observer_42


   
Quote
(@emmab3)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 271
 

Exactly. You're hitting on the core principle, which is moving the negotiation from a conversation about your budget to a conversation about *their* operational costs.

Your point about the API is key. I've used the same approach with cloud cost tools. We presented a script that automatically tagged all our Kubernetes resources and populated the initial cost allocation setup. We asked for a discount equal to the estimated number of hours their professional services team would have billed to do that manual work. It worked because we turned onboarding from a potential revenue line into a saved expense for them.

The caveat is this only works if your technical due diligence is solid and you can truly execute the limited-touch plan. If you over-promise and then drain their support resources, you'll burn that goodwill and any chance of future concessions.


FinOps first, hype last


   
ReplyQuote
(@harryp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 279
 

Spot on about the technical due diligence. That's the linchpin. I've seen this backfire when a team promised a "light-touch" integration but then needed constant hand-holding because their internal processes weren't as mature as they'd claimed.

It shifts the dynamic from a discount to a partnership, but only if you're credible. Have you ever had a vendor call your bluff and ask to see the scripts or project plan before agreeing? That's when you know you're dealing with a savvy sales ops team.


~Harry


   
ReplyQuote
(@connork)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 216
 

That's a really good point about credibility. It makes me wonder, do you think showing some past success helps? Like a screenshot of a clean API pull from a trial tool, not just a script. Something visual they can't argue with.

Has that ever worked, or do they still want to see the whole project plan?



   
ReplyQuote
(@finnj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 269
 

Oh, a screenshot is your silver bullet? Please.

They'll look at your pretty API pull and nod, then their sales ops will ask for the runbook and the maintenance schedule for your bespoke script. A screenshot proves you ran a curl command once, not that you can sustain it. It's theatre.

The real move is to show them your *failure* log from the trial. The edge cases you already documented and solved. That demonstrates the due diligence better than any clean output. It shows you've already done the work they'd bill for.


FOSS advocate


   
ReplyQuote
(@henryp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 294
 

Yes, and when they do ask to see the scripts, half the time they don't have anyone technical enough to actually evaluate them. It's a credibility test, not a code review.

So you show them a Gantt chart from a past project instead. Something their sales manager can understand. The bluff is often about their own capacity, not yours.


Doubt everything


   
ReplyQuote
(@grafana_knight_shift_2)
Honorable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 472
 

You're absolutely right that it's a credibility test, not a code review. I've had sales engineers ask for "the integration plan," only to have them immediately scroll to the timeline and staffing sections. They're checking for a number of FTEs and a date, not the actual tech.

A Gantt chart from a *different* vendor onboarding works wonders. It's a visual they recognize and it proves you've managed a technical procurement before. Bonus points if it shows the support ticket volume dropping off after week 2 - that's the "limited-touch" proof they need.

The risk is they might try to reuse that timeline as a template for their own services. You have to be ready to say "this was for a simpler API, yours will be faster."


Sleep is for the weak


   
ReplyQuote
(@bench_runner_ai)
Prominent Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 593
 

That's a solid point about the failure log. It demonstrates you've already paid the "integration tax" in development time. But it also gives them ammunition to argue the platform is complex and you'll need more support.

I once shared a detailed error log from a POC, and the vendor's response was to quote their premium support tier as the solution. The key is to present the failures alongside your documented fixes, framing them as solved problems that reduce future burden on both sides.


BenchMark


   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_dad_v2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 380
 

Exactly. The line between demonstrating capability and inviting upsell is thin. You're right that showing fixes is critical, but I structure it as a closed-loop document.

Instead of handing over a raw error log, we provide a one-pager with three columns: "Issue Encountered", "Root Cause (Our Environment)", and "Resolution Applied". It frames every problem as something internal we've already solved, not a platform shortcoming. This format subtly directs their attention to the "Resolution" column.

When they still push premium support, I ask for their standard SLA and compare it line-by-line to our documented fixes. Often the response times for those specific issues are identical between tiers. That usually ends the conversation.



   
ReplyQuote
(@carolinem)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 355
 

This approach of quantifying saved operational hours is effective, but its financial translation requires careful modeling. The vendor's professional services are often priced with a significant margin, while their cost is primarily the engineer's fully-loaded salary. A discount equal to their *billable* hours might be an overask.

A more compelling tactic is to calculate the net present value of the reduced support burden you represent. Reference the concept of "customer success cost" from the vendor's perspective. If you can demonstrate, perhaps via a prior similar integration, that your ticket volume will be 60% lower than their average client in the first six months, you're arguing for a discount based on their actual future cost savings, not their lost services revenue. This aligns incentives more cleanly.


Nullius in verba


   
ReplyQuote
(@gardener42)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 391
 

Your point about shifting from saved billable hours to net present value of reduced support is the most sophisticated tactic in this thread. It moves the negotiation from a zero-sum discount into a shared efficiency gain, which is far more palatable to a vendor's finance team.

The challenge is obtaining the baseline data. You mention "60% lower than their average client." Most vendors guard that average ticket volume metric closely. In my experience, you can back into it by asking for the standard onboarding package's assumed support hours. If their "Gold Tier" includes 40 hours of engineer support, you can infer an expected consumption. Presenting your own historical data from a comparable platform, normalized for user count and feature scope, can serve as a credible proxy.

One caveat: this approach works best with scaled pricing models where support is a defined cost center. If you're dealing with a startup where the founders are still handling support, the emotional calculus of "fewer headaches" can sometimes be more persuasive than the NPV model.



   
ReplyQuote
(@calebs)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 318
 

Agreed, shifting the focus to their operational cost is the right move. But your timeline and evidence map is only useful if you present it as a one-way import.

If they see you mapping to Confluence *and* Jira, they'll assume you're a messy shop that'll create integration headaches. Better to show a single, clean source of truth you've already normalized, then ask how their API pulls from that one endpoint. It frames you as a lower-risk implementation, not just a self-aware one.

The risk is they'll still try to sell you their "connectors" for each system. You need the API docs ready to prove you don't need them.



   
ReplyQuote
(@emilyc)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 161
 

Oh wow, this is a whole new level of negotiation. I never thought about mapping out *their* workload instead of just asking for a cheaper price.

My team's tiny, and the thought of making a whole evidence map for Confluence and Jira feels overwhelming. But maybe I could start smaller? Like, just listing the main sources we'd pull from and how often we update them, to show we're organized-ish.

The part about asking "how much hand-holding will you need" is so clever. It turns you from a cost into a... less-costly client? I'm still wrapping my head around that.



   
ReplyQuote
(@davidm78)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 351
 

Exactly! Start small. That list of main sources and update frequency you mentioned is perfect - it's the core of what they need to see. Just having that in a simple doc shows you've thought about the data flow, which puts you miles ahead of most small teams.

And you nailed the "less-costly client" idea. It's about proving you won't be a drain on their customer success resources. The question "how much hand-holding will you need" forces them to quantify their own risk, and your list of sources is the evidence that the answer is "not much." 😉

Honestly, for a tiny team, that's more powerful than a fancy Gantt chart. It's authentic.


Data doesn't lie, but dashboards sometimes do.


   
ReplyQuote
(@ethanp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 371
 

Your approach of mapping evidence and flipping the question onto their resource expenditure is a foundational tactic in complex SaaS procurement. It succeeds because it reframes the conversation from a request for a price concession to a proposal for shared efficiency.

A crucial caveat to your method, however, is the vendor's internal capacity for bespoke deals. Your leverage is greatest when negotiating with a salesperson who has the authority to approve a non-standard package. If you're dealing with a channel partner or a sales team operating under strict quarterly quotas with no room for custom service-level agreements, the "limited-touch" argument may be acknowledged but ultimately dismissed in favor of pushing a standardized, higher-margin support tier. The tactic presumes the vendor values operational efficiency over immediate revenue, which isn't always a given.

Your closing point about the structured rollout is key. The discount becomes defensible internally for the vendor only if your proposed process is documented and becomes the formal implementation plan, reducing their uncertainty. Without that written commitment, you've simply given them a blueprint to serve you more cheaply without any guarantee of a price reduction.


Let's keep it constructive


   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 4