Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Thoughts on the 'proprietary' rules in Semgrep Pro? any lock-in risk?

5 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
64 Views
(@emilyl)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 527
Topic starter   [#23304]

Hey everyone! I’ve been trying to get better at security scanning for our project management and collaboration tools (we use a lot of Asana, Notion, and Slack integrations). I’ve been exploring Semgrep for this, and I see they have a “Pro” version with what they call “proprietary” rules.

My team is pretty small and we’re trying to avoid vendor lock-in wherever possible. The idea of proprietary rules makes me a bit nervous. Like, if we build our CI/CD process around these specific Semgrep Pro rules and then decide to move away later, are we stuck? Do those rules just stop working, or can we not take them with us?

Also, are these rules *that* much better than what’s available in the open-source registry? I’m still learning, so it’s hard for me to judge the real value. I’d love to hear from anyone who’s used them in a remote team setting for productivity/collaboration app code. Are they more about compliance, or do they actually catch nuanced bugs in integration code that the community rules miss?

Thx!



   
Quote
(@charlie2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 345
 

Totally get the lock-in concern. We're a small team too and I'd hate to be stuck.

I've been using the open-source registry for Jira/Confluence integrations and honestly, it's pretty solid for common issues. But I've heard the Pro rules can catch more subtle stuff, like weird edge cases in how you handle API keys or webhook signatures. That might be worth it if you're in a regulated space.

Has anyone actually tried migrating away? Like, did you have to rewrite all your checks?



   
ReplyQuote
(@charlotte2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 337
 

Oh, you're worried about building your CI/CD around them and then getting stuck? That's the whole point.

The lock-in isn't just about the rules "stopping." It's that your team's security posture becomes defined by their secret sauce. You stop thinking about *why* a pattern is dangerous and just start relying on their curated list of boogeymen. If you leave, you're not just losing the rules, you're losing the context and the "nuanced bugs" they supposedly catch. Then you have to rebuild that institutional knowledge from scratch.

And are they *that* much better? For common integrations, probably not. The open-source registry is full of sharp people. The Pro rules are often just about catching the obscure stuff a compliance auditor might ask about, not the real, day-to-day integration bugs. So you're trading potential lock-in for... checkbox anxiety?


But what about the edge case?


   
ReplyQuote
(@charlieg)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 503
 

Proprietary rules are basically a subscription to a list of someone else's opinions. You're right to be nervous.

If you move away, the rules stop working. That's the business model. The real lock-in isn't technical, it's mental - you start outsourcing your team's understanding of what "secure" means for your specific tools. The open-source rules for those platforms are written by people who actually had the bugs, not a vendor trying to justify a seat license.

The "nuanced bugs" they catch are often just compliance theater for audits. You'll get a dozen obscure findings about OAuth flows you don't even use, while missing the obvious Slack webhook logging your own team wrote last week. Start with the registry, learn why those rules exist, and write your own for your actual code.


cg


   
ReplyQuote
(@danielr23)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 359
 

The lock-in is real, but the risk is manageable. You can treat Pro rules as a temporary accelerator.

Import them, but track what they catch. Every finding should prompt you to ask: "Can we write an equivalent open-source rule for this pattern?" Do that. Over time, you'll replace the Pro coverage with your own understood rulesets. The proprietary rules become a training dataset, not a dependency.

For Asana/Notion/Slack integrations, the open-source registry is weak on context-specific leaks. Pro rules might flag a Notion API key in a specific client constructor pattern. That's the nuance - but you can codify that pattern yourself once you see it. Start with OSS, then run a Pro trial *specifically* to see what you're missing and internalize it.


Trust, but verify


   
ReplyQuote