Hey everyone. I'm pretty new to DevOps, coming from a sysadmin background, so I might be missing something obvious here.
I enabled push protection on our repo, and it's flagging *everything*. Like, it blocked a push because a config file had a placeholder like `API_KEY=your_key_here`. It feels like it's catching stuff that isn't really a secret. Is this normal? How do you all manage the noise without just turning it off? I want the security, but my team is getting frustrated with the false positives.
Totally get the frustration! That initial noise is really common when you first turn it on. The "your_key_here" type flagging is because the scanner uses regex patterns - it sees `API_KEY=` and a string after it and throws an alert, even for placeholders.
What worked for us was setting up a `secret_scanning.yml` custom patterns file to exclude those placeholder patterns. You can also add paths to ignore, like `**/config/template*.json`.
It gets a lot quieter after you train it for a week or two with those custom filters. Did you try the "allow" feature for a specific finding yet? That helps the scanner learn over time.
Clean code, happy life
Yeah, that's a common pain point when you first enable it. It's scanning based on pattern matching, so placeholders in config templates or example files will trigger it every time.
We hit the same wall. The trick is to aggressively use the "allow" button for those first few false positives and also review your default patterns list in the security settings. Some of the generic API key patterns are just too broad for active development.
Once you allow a few, the noise drops dramatically. Have you looked at whether the flagged files are even in your main branch or just in feature branches?
The placeholder detection is a necessary trade-off. They'd rather block a fake key than miss a real one that happens to be formatted as `your_key_here`.
Start by using the "allow" feature, but then immediately define custom patterns to exclude your known placeholders. Otherwise you'll just be clicking "allow" forever.
If your config templates are consistently named, add them to the push protection path exclusions. A pattern like `**/*.template` or `**/config/examples/*` can save you a lot of grief.
Your fancy demo doesn't scale.
Oh man, that's a classic onboarding experience. I had the same "block-all-the-things" shock with our Terraform modules. It flagged every `example.tfvars` file with placeholder values.
What saved us was a two-step approach: first, use the "allow" feature to unblock immediate pushes, but then *immediately* go into the repo's security settings and set up path exclusions. We added patterns like `**/examples/**` and `**/*.template.*`. The noise dropped by about 80% that same day.
You can also tweak the pattern severity for things like generic API keys. Sometimes just lowering it from "high" to "medium" lets the push go through but still logs it for review. Hang in there - it gets way better!
Infrastructure as code is the only way
Yeah, the Terraform example hits home. I've seen the same thing with `.env.example` files in our Node projects. The path exclusions are a lifesaver, but I'd add one caveat - watch out for nested templates in unusual directories.
We added `**/*.example.*` and thought we were covered, but then it flagged a `secrets.template.yaml` inside a `charts/` folder because our pattern missed it. Ended up needing a broader `**/*template*` catch-all.
Have you noticed if lowering the pattern severity from high to medium actually reduces the *push blocking*? Or does it just change the alert level in the dashboard? I've been meaning to test that.
editor is my home
Oh yeah, that placeholder block is a rite of passage! It's totally normal to feel swamped at first.
I'd double down on the path exclusions everyone's mentioning - that's the fastest fix. Our team also made a simple rule: any new repo gets a `.github/secret_scanning.yml` file from a template *before* anyone codes. That way, patterns for `**/*.example`, `**/templates/**`, and our common placeholder formats are already ignored from day one.
It quiets down a lot once you carve out those safe spaces for your template files. Did the "allow" button help unblock your team while you set up the exclusions?
null