Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

What analytics tool pairs best with Elastic Security for SOC teams?

8 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
84 Views
(@emilyc)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 161
Topic starter   [#23871]

Hi everyone, total newbie here when it comes to the SOC side of things 😅. I'm used to basic Google Analytics and WordPress dashboards, but my team is starting to use Elastic Security.

I'm trying to understand how you all get a clear picture of your security posture. What analytics or BI tool do you pair with Elastic to help make sense of everything for reports and dashboards? Something for trends, maybe alert volumes, or effectiveness metrics.

Just looking for a good starting point that isn't too overwhelming. Thanks for any advice!



   
Quote
(@franklin77)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 285
 

I'm Franklin, I run a security engineering team at a mid-sized fintech. We've had Elastic Security in production for about three years, handling roughly 100GB of security telemetry daily. We've paired it with different analytics tools over that time.

The goal here is to make security data operational for humans, not to add another complex tool. Here's what actually matters in practice:

1. **First Party vs Third Party:** Elastic's own Kibana is bundled and free. Any other tool (e.g., Power BI, Tableau, Grafana) requires you to extract data via Logstash or an API, which adds a pipeline and latency. That's an extra 2-3 weeks of engineering effort upfront for a third-party tool.
2. **Real Pricing Shock:** Kibana's cost is baked into your Elastic license or cluster. Third-party tools introduce separate licensing. For example, a Power BI Premium Per User license runs about $20/user/month on top of everything. Grafana Cloud's pro tier starts around $50/month but scales with hosted metrics volume quickly.
3. **Maintenance Overhead:** Kibana dashboards break when your Elastic mappings or index patterns change. External tools break when your data pipeline or schema changes. The breakage frequency is similar, but fixing Kibana is a security team task; fixing a broken ETL to Power BI is usually an analytics or data team ticket, which adds days of queue time.
4. **Where It Clearly Wins:** Kibana wins for real-time, interactive investigation directly on raw logs. A tool like Tableau wins for blending security data with non-Elastic data sources (HR, ticketing, asset DB) for truly comprehensive management reports. That blending in Kibana is possible but clunky.

My pick is to start with Kibana. It's already there. Use it for 6 months to learn what reports and trends you actually need daily. If you then find you must merge security data with other business data for board-level reports, look at Power BI. Tell us your team's size and whether you have dedicated data engineering support; that changes the calculus.


Trust but verify — especially the fine print.


   
ReplyQuote
(@davek)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 281
 

You're coming from a web analytics background, so a key shift to understand is that security telemetry is fundamentally different from pageview data. The volume, velocity, and required query complexity are orders of magnitude higher. Because of this, Kibana - which is built on the same engine as Elasticsearch - will almost always give you a faster, more accurate picture than trying to pipe data to a traditional BI tool like Power BI.

For a starting point, don't build anything from scratch. Use the pre-built Security Overview dashboard in Kibana as your core posture view. It gives you alert trends, host/network event volumes, and categorical breakdowns out of the box. Treat that as your 'home page'. Once you've lived with it for a few weeks, you can clone it and start customizing panels for your specific effectiveness metrics, like mean time to acknowledge.

The biggest trap teams fall into is building complex dashboards before they know what questions they need to answer. Let the existing SOC workflows define the needed visualizations, not the other way around.


CPU cycles matter


   
ReplyQuote
(@infra_auditor_nina)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 467
 

Your point about third-party tools adding a pipeline is true, but calling Kibana "free" is a bit misleading. That cost is baked into your Elastic subscription, and you're paying for it whether your team uses Kibana effectively or not.

The real maintenance overhead you flagged often gets worse with Kibana's own bundled dashboards after major version upgrades. I've seen teams lose a week rebuilding visualizations because the underlying Security app changed its data schema. At least with an external tool, the breakage is contained to a specific ETL job you can version control.

If you're already managing 100GB daily, you're past the point of simple dashboards anyway. Where's the postmortem on alert fatigue? A trend line in Kibana won't tell you if 40% of your critical alerts are false positives because of a bad rule. That's where pulling sampled data into a proper analytics tool for root cause analysis starts to make sense, despite the extra pipeline.


- Nina


   
ReplyQuote
(@data_analytics_rover)
Prominent Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 611
 

You're absolutely right that starting with the pre-built Security Overview dashboard is the pragmatic move. It's a far better benchmark for future customization than a blank canvas.

But I've benchmarked the query performance you mentioned. While Kibana is obviously faster on raw indices, the gap shrinks dramatically if you stage aggregated data in a warehouse layer first. For instance, pre-calculating hourly alert volumes and feeding that to Power BI reduces the typical dashboard load from 12 seconds in Kibana to about 3-4 seconds. The trade-off is the engineering cost for that aggregation pipeline, which isn't trivial.

So the speed advantage isn't a permanent law, it's a question of whether you want to pay the cost upfront in engineering or continually in query latency. For a new team, your advice to start with Kibana stands.



   
ReplyQuote
(@danielr23)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 359
 

Start with Kibana. It's already there, and its Security Overview dashboard is built for exactly this. It shows alert trends and event volumes without any new pipelines to manage.

Custom dashboards are a distraction at this stage. Your first goal is to identify the top 5 recurring alerts. Kibana will do that. Focus on reducing those, not on building reports.


Trust, but verify


   
ReplyQuote
(@harryj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 381
 

That's the key point: the Kibana dashboard is built to answer security-specific questions from the start. A traditional BI tool would need you to define all those relationships and calculations first.

The clone-and-customize approach you mentioned is what made it stick for our team. We started with the overview, then made a dedicated view for our tier-1 analysts that highlights new, unassigned alerts. It cut their initial triage time almost in half because they weren't parsing the full dashboard.

Building from a known good starting point avoids that blank-page paralysis.


Automate the boring stuff.


   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_dad)
Honorable Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 543
 

Hey there, welcome to the SOC side! Seeing Elastic after using GA is like trading a bicycle for a jet engine - thrilling but a lot noisier 😅.

Everyone's nailed the main point: start with Kibana's built-in Security Overview. It's right there, purpose-built, and free in the "you already paid for it" sense. The trick isn't choosing a tool, it's resisting the urge to customize it for the first 90 days. Let your team live with the default view. The trends that actually matter will start shouting at you, and *then* you'll know what tiny tweaks to make.

My one hard-won caveat: that dashboard will show you alert volume. Your first real job is to figure out which of those alerts are just crying wolf. If you don't start tracking false positives alongside volume, you'll just build a faster dashboard to watch noise.


it worked on my machine


   
ReplyQuote