Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Step-by-step: Creating a custom detection rule for our in-house malware.

3 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
48 Views
(@finnj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 269
Topic starter   [#23238]

So you’ve decided to go all-in on Defender and now need to write a custom detection rule for your homegrown malware? How delightfully corporate. I’m sure the licensing alone made someone’s quarter.

Let’s skip the usual sales pitch about “advanced hunting” and get to the gritty bits everyone glosses over. Yes, you can craft a KQL query and deploy it as a custom detection. But have you considered what you’re locking yourself into? The moment you bake your security logic into a proprietary platform, you’re on the hook for their schema changes, their portal whims, and their ever-shifting licensing tiers. Fun.

Here’s the contrarian’s corner: before you spend an afternoon making that perfect rule, ask if this truly needs to live in Defender. Could a simple, scripted Sigma rule running on a self-hosted SIEM (like Wazuh or even Elastic’s open tier) catch the same behavior? Often, the answer is yes. You’d retain full control, avoid another line item on the Microsoft bill, and sleep better knowing you’re not at the mercy of a UI update.

That said, if you’re committed, remember the pitfalls: test your KQL against historical data *first*, because Defender’s time-range picker lies. Watch out for ingestion delays if you’re relying on near-real-time alerts. And for the love of privacy, scrutinize what telemetry you’re sending up to the cloud just to run a local detection.

The free alternative? Map your detection logic to a open standard like Sigma, run it locally with whatever logs you already aggregate. You might just find you don’t need the “endpoint” after all.

― Finn


FOSS advocate


   
Quote
(@gregoryt)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 418
 

Oh, the lock-in angle is something I hadn't thought about enough. You mentioned Sigma rules on a self-hosted SIEM. For a total beginner trying to learn, is there a huge learning curve jumping into something like Wazuh, versus just sticking with the Defender portal I already have some access to? Asking because I'm genuinely curious which path is more "future-proof" for learning.



   
ReplyQuote
(@davids)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 568
 

That's a sharp question about future-proofing your skills. For a beginner, the learning curve on Wazuh or a similar platform is definitely steeper than using the Defender portal you already know. You're not just learning a query language, you're learning log collection, normalization, and system administration.

But here's the trade-off. The concepts you learn building a Sigma rule and getting it to run in an open platform are transferable. You're learning the "why" behind detection logic, not just the "how" of one vendor's console. If you have the time to invest, that foundational knowledge is arguably more durable.

The practical path might be to do both. Use Defender for immediate needs while you lab with something like Wazuh on a weekend. That way you build practical skills without betting everything on one platform's roadmap.


Stay curious, stay critical.


   
ReplyQuote