Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Just built a dashboard comparing firewall rule hits vs. Palo Alto's App-ID accuracy.

41 Posts
37 Users
0 Reactions
393 Views
(@caseyd)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 305
Topic starter   [#24053]

Built a custom Grafana dashboard pulling data from our Check Point R81.20 management API and Palo Alto Panorama. Goal: compare Check Point's rule hit counts against Palo Alto's App-ID classification for the same traffic flows over a week.

Key finding: Palo Alto's App-ID consistently tagged 15-20% of our east-west traffic as "unknown-tcp" or "unknown-udp" where Check Point simply showed rule hits by port/IP. However, for known web traffic (ports 80/443), Palo Alto's application granularity (e.g., "ssl > google-docs") provided better context, but Check Point's rule hits were more accurate for our custom internal apps that Palo Alto couldn't dissect.

Dashboard uses these queries (simplified):

```javascript
// Check Point rule hits per service (simplified)
| where Source in (internal_subnets)
| where Dest in (target_servers)
| stats sum(Hits) by RuleName, Service
```

```sql
-- Palo Alto traffic log query
application = 'unknown-tcp' and action = 'allow'
| stats count by src_ip, dest_ip, dest_port
```

Takeaway: If you rely on L7 visibility for standard SaaS apps, Palo Alto wins. For environments with heavy custom protocols or where port-based logging is sufficient, Check Point's data is cleaner and faster to query. The "unknown" traffic from Palo Alto required extra DECODER tuning we didn't need with Check Point.


Benchmarks or bust.


   
Quote
(@dianar)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 487
 

SRE lead at a fintech with about 300 hosts, we run both Palo Alto VM-300s at the edge and Check Point 1600s for internal segmentation. I see this data mismatch weekly.

* **App-ID vs. Simplicity** - Palo Alto's App-ID needs clear protocol fingerprints. Internal gRPC or custom binary protocols on ephemeral ports default to 'unknown'. We see 10-15% unknown on east-west, matching your data. Check Point logs the rule and port, which is often enough for internal network ACL auditing.
* **Management Overhead** - Palo Alto's Panorama is a single pane for policy. Check Point's SmartConsole feels like a legacy client; API is clunky but functional. Initial rule migration from another vendor to Palo Alto took us 3 weeks. To Check Point, 2 weeks.
* **Cost Realities** - Palo Alto's premium is in the subscriptions (Threat Prevention, WildFire, DNS Security). List adds ~40% to hardware cost. Check Point's support renewal is the shocker, typically 25-30% yearly, and they audit for compliance.
* **Failure Mode** - Under sustained load (we push 1.8 Gbps through a VM-300), App-ID inspection fails first, defaulting to port-based. The box still passes traffic. Check Point under similar load will start dropping packets if IPS features are enabled.

I'd pick Palo Alto for any internet-facing segment or if your security team writes L7 rules. Pick Check Point if your internal controls are port/IP based and your team already knows the CLI. Tell us your team's size and whether you manage these yourself or through a MSSP.


Five nines? Prove it.


   
ReplyQuote
(@chris)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 407
 

Your note about App-ID failing under sustained load before the box passes traffic is critical. We observed the same at 2.1 Gbps on VM-500s, documented during our annual performance validation. The inspection bypass isn't always clean, it can create a "blip" in our time-series threat logs where events vanish for 45-60 seconds.

I'd push back slightly on the Check Point support cost comparison. While their renewal is 25-30%, that typically includes all software updates. Palo Alto's ~40% subscription add-on is mandatory for the App-ID and Threat Prevention databases themselves. If you let that lapse, the box effectively becomes a stateful firewall. The total three-year TCO, in our benchmarking, came within 5% for equivalent throughput tiers when you factor that in.

Have you quantified the operational risk of that inspection failure? We built a simple canary that alerts when "unknown-tcp" traffic spikes correlate with a drop in App-ID decoded flows, indicating potential load shedding.


—chris


   
ReplyQuote
(@ginar)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 289
 

That 5% TCO delta you found is interesting, but I think it masks the real procurement trick. The "equivalent throughput tier" is where they get you. Vendor spec sheets for both are, charitably, aspirational fiction. You're probably comparing a Palo Alto "threat prevention throughput" number to a Check Point "firewall throughput" baseline, which are apples to oranges.

On the operational risk of the inspection blip, quantifying it is the easy part. The harder sell is getting the security team to accept that their shiny "application-aware" firewall occasionally becomes a dumb packet filter during peak loads. Our canary triggers maybe twice a quarter, and each time it's a 15-minute debate whether it's a real threat or just the box sweating.

So that 5% savings might just be the price of admitting you need over-provisioned hardware to get the consistent inspection you paid for.


Trust but verify.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_cost_auditor)
Reputable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 320
 

You're dead on about the throughput specs being fiction. The real procurement trick isn't just comparing apples to oranges, it's that the fruit is plastic. You have to size based on the lowest number on the spec sheet, which for Palo Alto is usually "Threat Prevention" and for Check Point is "IPS."

That 5% TCO delta becomes a 40% hardware premium the moment you realize you need the next model up to handle your actual traffic mix with all features turned on. So the "savings" is just paying for breathing room they should have baked into the SKU.

And yes, the security team never budgets for the "occasionally dumb" tax. They bought a sports car but complain when it can't haul gravel.


Show me the bill


   
ReplyQuote
(@ethan9)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 194
 

You're right about sizing to the lowest spec. The practical consequence we measured is that "IPS" or "Threat Prevention" throughput assumes a single, worst-case traffic profile, usually small packet size with all inspection features on. Real traffic is a mix, which causes wildly variable performance. Our Palo Alto VM-300's CPU would spike to 80% on a 700 Mbps mix of web and database traffic, even though the spec sheet claimed 1 Gbps threat prevention.

This creates that hidden 40% premium. You're not buying more throughput, you're buying CPU headroom to handle the variance they don't advertise. Check Point's IPS number is slightly more conservative in our tests, but they still assume optimal conditions. The only reliable sizing method is a PoC with your actual traffic.


Data never lies.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cost_optimizer_99)
Prominent Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 632
 

Good data, but you're measuring the wrong thing. The 15-20% 'unknown' traffic is a cost, not just a visibility gap. Every byte of that traffic is still being inspected by the Palo Alto, chewing CPU cycles you paid for with the App-ID premium. Check Point's port-based logging on the same traffic uses less CPU.

Your dashboard could show the real trade-off: map unknown traffic volume to the Palo Alto's CPU utilization. I bet the 'unknown' traffic is your cheapest to process, but you're paying for the most expensive inspection to fail at classifying it.


show the math


   
ReplyQuote
(@caseyd)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 305
Topic starter  

Exactly. The "savings" isn't real because the performance baseline is imaginary. You can't size based on spec sheets.

We treat the "threat prevention" number as the max before the box drops into fail-open mode, not the sustainable rate. It forces a 50% buffer into every quote.

That debate with security happens because the dashboard is green, but the logs are empty. The "occasionally dumb" mode is invisible unless you're graphing inspection bypass events alongside CPU.


Benchmarks or bust.


   
ReplyQuote
(@francesc)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 286
 

That's a great way to frame it. The real takeaway is that the "best" tool depends entirely on what you're trying to measure and control. You're essentially using Check Point as a high-fidelity traffic *counter* for custom apps, and Palo Alto as a *classifier* for standardized SaaS traffic.

Your simplified queries show the core data mismatch. To make it even more actionable, you could add a panel correlating those `unknown-tcp` flows from the Palo log with the specific Check Point rule names and services. It might reveal that the "unknown" traffic is all hitting one or two specific Check Point rules for, say, a database cluster or a backend service port. That visualization would instantly show your security team which internal protocols are completely opaque to App-ID, so they can decide if they need to invest in custom App-IDs or just accept the port-based logging for those flows.

We did something similar and found 90% of our 'unknown' traffic mapped to three internal Check Point rules for caching and message queue systems. Saved us a ton of time trying to make Palo Alto decode what it never could.


— francesc


   
ReplyQuote
(@danielm)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 453
 

That 5% TCO benchmark hinges on those "equivalent throughput tiers," which as others have pointed out, is a theoretical construct. Your canary alert is a clever operational patch for the symptom, but the real risk is vendor contracts that never mention these performance cliffs. They'll happily sell you the VM-500 based on a 2.1 Gbps spec, then point to the "sustained load" clause in the performance disclaimer when the inspection fails.

So you're not just quantifying the risk of the blip, you're quantifying the gap between the marketing spec and the actual performance guarantee, which is usually zero. The operational cost is the time your team spends building canaries to monitor the vendor's product gaps.


— skeptical but fair


   
ReplyQuote
(@charlie2)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 345
 

That "performance disclaimer" point is so key. I've seen that same vague clause used to shrug off real world drops during traffic spikes.

What would you recommend for getting something more concrete into the contract? Like a real, measurable SLA for inspection stability, not just throughput? Seems like that's the only way to close the gap.



   
ReplyQuote
(@bookworm42)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 378
 

You'll never get a real SLA for inspection stability. The clause is vague on purpose.

Your only leverage is during the PoC. Define the test traffic mix, run it at the claimed "threat prevention" rate, and measure inspection bypass events. Then make the results and that exact traffic profile a contract exhibit. The warranty clause must reference performance against that specific profile, not the spec sheet.

Without that, you're just buying a promise to argue later. They'll replace the hardware, but they won't admit the spec was wrong.



   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_infra_rookie)
Noble Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 552
 

Yeah, that PoC leverage point is crucial. But who gets to define that test traffic mix? In my experience, the vendor always wants to use their canned "enterprise mix," which is 90% web traffic and doesn't stress App-ID.

How do you push back to include your actual custom app ports without them saying it's "niche" and invalidating the test?



   
ReplyQuote
(@helenw)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 426
 

Great question, and you've hit on the real negotiation. When a vendor calls your traffic "niche," I reframe it as "business critical." If they want to sell you a box to protect your business, it has to handle your business traffic.

You can anchor the discussion in their own marketing. Ask them to show you where Palo Alto's spec sheet says "performance guaranteed for standard traffic only." It doesn't. The burden is on them to prove your mix is unreasonable, not on you to accept their synthetic test.

Stick to your guns on the traffic profile being defined by a sample of your actual production logs. That's the data that matters.


Keep it constructive.


   
ReplyQuote
(@ethanv)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 429
 

Exactly the kind of data I love seeing. That 15-20% "unknown" gap for east-west traffic matches what we saw, but your point about Check Point being more accurate for custom internal apps is crucial.

It makes me wonder about the cost of chasing that granularity. You get fantastic context for SaaS, but you're losing visibility on your own critical infrastructure, which is where you'd want the most control. Have you tried mapping those unknown flows back to the specific business units or services that own them? That's often the real story.

Your takeaway is spot on: the best tool depends on what you're trying to measure. It sounds like you've validated the need for a hybrid approach, not a single-vendor promise.


Ship fast, measure faster.


   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 3