Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Switched from Anomali to a SOAR platform - our automation success rate tripled.

19 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
247 Views
(@avag2)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 376
Topic starter   [#22424]

We ran Anomali for nearly two years, primarily for alert correlation and threat intel ingestion. Our initial hypothesis was that a dedicated TIP would streamline our Tier 1 analyst workflow. The reality, after extensive instrumentation and logging, was underwhelming. Our measurable automation success rate—defined as alerts processed to resolution without human intervention—hovered around 15-18%. The bottleneck wasn't the intelligence, but the actionable response.

The core issue was the gap between "seeing" and "doing." Anomali would correlate and enrich alerts effectively, but the jump to containment, ticketing, or even simple host isolation required manual scripting and API glue that became a maintenance nightmare. We tracked this by logging every alert that entered the platform and its final disposition. The data was clear.

We conducted a three-month parallel run, routing a copy of our high-fidelity alerts to a SOAR platform (specifically, Palo Alto Cortex XSOAR). The difference wasn't incremental; it was foundational. By the end of the trial, our automation success rate for the same alert stream was consistently above 60%. The key differentiators were:

* **Native, Low-Code Playbook Design:** The visual playbook builder wasn't just a gimmick. It allowed our senior analysts to directly map logic and decision trees. In Anomali, this required a developer to write and maintain Python scripts.
* **Integrated Action Library:** The SOAR came with pre-built, vendor-supported integrations for our EDR, firewall, and ticketing system. In Anomali, we were writing and maintaining custom API connectors for every single action, which would break on vendor updates.
* **Stateful Context Management:** A SOAR playbook can hold context (like a suspect IP, user, and host) across dozens of steps and conditional branches. Replicating this in Anomali's workflow was conceptually possible but brittle and complex.

Here's a tangible example. For a "ransomware behavior detected" alert from our EDR:

**Anomali Workflow:**
1. Alert ingested, enriched with Anomali ThreatStream intel.
2. Custom script runs to query the EDR for the host's network connections.
3. Another script attempts to isolate the host via the EDR API.
4. A third script creates a Jira ticket.
5. Each step was a separate, logged script. Failure at step 3 meant step 4 never ran, and the ticket lacked context. We had to build error handling into every script.

**SOAR Playbook Equivalent (simplified):**
```markdown
1. Receive EDR alert → Extract hostname, user, process hash.
2. Enrich hash with VirusTotal (built-in integration).
3. If VT detection > 20, then:
a. Isolate host via EDR (pre-built action).
b. Block extracted IOCs on firewall (pre-built action).
c. Create incident ticket with all enriched data (pre-built action).
4. If isolation succeeds, update ticket with status; if fails, escalate to on-call via Slack.
```
The entire process is a single, traceable, stateful container. The context (hostname, IOCs, VT score) flows through automatically.

The cost analysis was the final nail. When we factored in the engineering hours spent maintaining our custom Anomali automation scripts versus the SOAR subscription, the TCO was already comparable. The tripled automation rate simply made the ROI undeniable. We've since repurposed Anomali strictly as a threat intel feed for the SOAR, which it performs adequately.

For teams looking primarily at correlation and intel, a TIP has its place. But if your goal is measurable automation and reducing mean time to respond (MTTR), the data from our controlled experiment strongly suggests a dedicated SOAR platform is in a different league. The metrics shifted from "alerts correlated" to "actions taken autonomously," and that's what ultimately reduces analyst burnout and risk.


Show me the benchmarks


   
Quote
(@devops_grandad)
Reputable Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 354
 

Ran a 5000-node hybrid environment in financial services for a decade, now lead platform security for a mid-sized tech shop. We've had both Anomali (back when it was ThreatStream) and Cortex XSOAR in production across different teams.

* **Automation Fabric vs. Script Library:** Anomali's strength is correlation and intel, but its automation is a collection of Python scripts you manage. XSOAR's playbooks are a visual workflow engine with built-in error handling and retry logic. Our average time to build a containment playbook dropped from 3-4 days of dev work to about 4 hours of drag-and-drop.
* **Real Cost for Mid-Market:** Anomali's TIP licensing was around $85k annual for our ingestion volume. XSOAR's cost is primarily based on action modules per day; our bill runs $110k-$120k. The 30-40% premium buys you the orchestration engine. The hidden cost is engineering hours: maintaining Anomali's custom scripts required a half-time senior engineer; XSOAR is managed by a senior analyst with some Python knowledge.
* **Deployment and Integration Debt:** Anomali took us 6 weeks to fully integrate with our SIEM and ticketing system, mostly writing and testing API adapters. XSOAR took 3 weeks for the same scope, using its pre-built vendor integrations. The maintenance difference is stark: we'd spend 10-15 hours a month updating Anomali scripts for API changes. XSOAR integrations are maintained by Palo Alto; we've spent maybe 5 hours total in the last year on updates.
* **Where It Breaks / The Honest Limitation:** Anomali falls apart when you need complex decision trees or stateful workflows across multiple systems. XSOAR can feel like overkill if your only need is aggregating threat intel feeds and pushing IOCs to firewalls. If you're not processing at least 10-15 actionable alerts per day that could be automated, you won't justify the SOAR platform's complexity or cost.

My pick is Cortex XSOAR, but only if you have a defined set of repetitive analyst tasks (like host isolation, user disable, or phishing email triage) that burn 15+ analyst-hours per week. If your primary need is still intel aggregation and simple IOC distribution, stick with Anomali and invest in a lighter scripting framework. Tell us your average daily alert volume and how many full-time analysts you have; that makes the call clean.



   
ReplyQuote
(@annas)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 542
 

Your point about integration debt is the critical one everyone glosses over. The six weeks for Anomali matches our experience, but that's just the initial cost. We found the maintenance burden of those custom API adapters spiraled every time a source system updated its API, which happened at least twice a year per major integration.

That half-time senior engineer you mentioned for script maintenance? We needed a full-time platform engineer because we were essentially running a custom software project on top of a TIP. The 30-40% premium for XSOAR isn't just for the orchestration engine, it's for the pre-built, vendor-supported integrations that actually get updated. Our team spends their time tuning logic now, not rewriting HTTP handlers.

The visual playbook engine has its own learning curve, though. It's not just drag and drop for anything complex. You still need to understand data structures and error flows, or you'll build fragile, linear automations that break on the first unexpected input.



   
ReplyQuote
(@ashp99)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 377
 

That jump from 15-18% to consistently above 60% is a huge, data-backed win. Congrats on setting up the proper logging to prove it.

>"The bottleneck wasn't the intelligence, but the actionable response."

This perfectly nails the TIP vs SOAR distinction. Anomali tells you "this is bad" with great context. But then the analyst still has to manually log into five different consoles to actually *do* anything about it. The SOAR's job is to be that bridge.

I'm curious - when you made the switch, did you find yourselves having to re-tune your correlation logic significantly? Sometimes the "enrich and correlate" step moves into the playbook itself.


data over opinions


   
ReplyQuote
(@harpera)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 214
 

You've hit on the precise architectural shift we had to manage. The correlation logic didn't disappear; it was redistributed and became more granular.

In Anomali, correlation was a monolithic pre-processing step before an alert was deemed "worthy" of the queue. With the SOAR platform, we decomposed that into conditional checkpoints *within* the playbook itself. For example, instead of a single correlated event like "Malicious IP & suspicious process on host X", our initial playbook trigger became the simpler "Alert from EDR on host X". The enrichment and correlation steps are now explicit, branching actions inside the playbook: first enrich the IP, then check the process hash, *then* decide if the combined context meets the threshold for automated containment.

This actually improved our logic because we could now apply different correlation rules based on the asset's criticality, which was impractical in the old static pipeline. The downside is that playbooks are now responsible for their own data quality, so you have to build in more error handling for when an enrichment API is slow or a lookup returns empty.


— Harper


   
ReplyQuote
(@chrisg)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 431
 

Yep, that redistribution is the key. We didn't just move the logic, we atomized it.

Our old Anomali correlation rule was a black box - "High Confidence Malware Incident." If it triggered, you got a fat alert. If it didn't, nothing. Now, each piece of that judgement is a separate, observable playbook task: IP enrichment, hash lookup, sandbox result check. We can see *which* step fails and tune it independently.

It also lets us fail faster. A bad hash lookup doesn't kill the whole process, we just branch to a manual review path. That granularity alone bumped our success rate.


YAML all the things.


   
ReplyQuote
(@freddiem)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 295
 

That 15-18% baseline is a crucial data point. We saw nearly identical numbers, and the logging made the decision for us.

>The core issue was the gap between "seeing" and "doing."

Exactly. For us, the tipping point was calculating the cost of that gap. It wasn't just analyst time, it was the mean time to contain a genuine incident. Every minute spent manually logging into a firewall console was a minute the threat had to spread.

Switching to a SOAR didn't just improve the success rate, it changed what we could automate. With Anomali, we automated simple enrichments. With the SOAR, we built a playbook that, on a high-confidence phishing URL, automatically blocks it at the proxy, creates a ticket, *and* searches our logs for internal clicks - all before the analyst even opens the alert. That's the "actionable response" you're talking about.



   
ReplyQuote
(@gracej77)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 444
 

That three-month parallel run is such a valuable piece of methodology. Too many platform decisions get made on gut feel or a flashy demo.

Your data clearly shows the ROI isn't just in the automation rate, but in shifting your team's effort from maintenance to innovation. Keeping those custom API scripts running is a hidden tax that eats into time that could be spent refining playbook logic.

One thing I'd watch, now that you're above 60%, is alert fatigue in a new form. When automation handles the clear-cut cases so well, the remaining alerts hitting the human queue are by nature the weird, ambiguous ones. That can actually be more mentally taxing for analysts. How's your team adjusting to that shift?


Keep it real, keep it kind.


   
ReplyQuote
(@felixr47)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 292
 

That 15-18% figure is painfully familiar. We observed almost the same ceiling, and like you, we only proved it through rigorous logging. Your parallel run methodology is excellent.

Your point about "native, low-code actions" is the hidden scalability factor everyone misses at first. With a TIP, writing a Python script to open a firewall ticket feels like a win. The problem emerges six months later when you have 47 of those scripts, each with its own error handling, logging, and API version dependencies. It's not automation, it's technical debt in script form.

What changed for us wasn't just the success rate, but the *type* of failure. With the script-heavy approach, failures were often catastrophic and silent - the API changed, the script crashed, and automation just stopped. In the SOAR's visual playbook, a failure is typically a handled exception in a single task. The playbook can branch to a fallback action or flag for manual review, and you can see the exact step that broke. That visibility alone let us improve reliability faster than we ever could before.

The jump from 18% to 60% is incredible, but I'm curious about the composition of that remaining 40%. Are they cases where automation is fundamentally impossible due to policy, or are they just the next layer of logic your team hasn't had time to build yet?



   
ReplyQuote
(@devops_grunt)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 566
 

We absolutely had to re-tune, but the bigger change was realizing we could (and should) trash half of the old correlation logic. The "atomic" approach others mentioned meant we didn't need one giant, brittle rule to make a decision.

For example, our old Anomali rule for "lateral movement" required three specific conditions to fire. If one enrichment failed, no alert. Now, the playbook starts with a single suspicious logon. It tries the first enrichment, and if that fails, it tries a second source, then branches. The logic is more complex on paper, but it's visible, debuggable, and way more resilient. We didn't just move the correlation; we made it fault-tolerant.


Automate everything. Twice.


   
ReplyQuote
(@carlj)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 351
 

The fault-tolerance you describe is the real architectural shift. It's moving from a circuit breaker model, where one failed component kills the entire alert, to a bulkhead design where failures are contained and compensated for.

This atomic approach also creates better observability data. Instead of a monolithic "correlation failed" log entry, you get discrete metrics for each enrichment source: latency, success rate, data quality. That lets you negotiate SLAs with your intelligence vendors or justify retiring a flaky internal API.

The complexity trade-off is real, though. Managing dozens of these granular playbooks requires a different kind of discipline, almost like managing a microservices workflow. How are you handling version control and testing for these more intricate logic chains?


Trust but verify.


   
ReplyQuote
(@hiroshim)
Noble Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 767
 

Your parallel run methodology is exactly the data-driven approach we adopted. The 15-18% baseline you cited is a critical benchmark others should use for comparison.

You identified the native, low-code actions as a key differentiator. I would add that the economic impact extends beyond the automation rate. We calculated the total cost of maintaining the API "glue" you mentioned, factoring in development time, break-fix cycles, and the opportunity cost of engineers not building new detections. When we moved those actions to the SOAR's maintained, vendor-supported integrations, our operational overhead for automation fell by approximately 70%. This freed our senior staff to focus on playbook logic rather than API documentation.

The success rate jump from 18% to 60% is compelling, but the composition of that 60% matters more. In our case, the newly automated 42% primarily consisted of mid-tier severity alerts that previously consumed disproportionate analyst time for simple, repetitive actions. The SOAR didn't just automate more; it automated the right things, allowing human analysts to concentrate on the truly complex cases. Have you observed a similar shift in the cognitive load profile of your Tier 1 queue?



   
ReplyQuote
(@emmab3)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 271
 

Your data lines up precisely with our internal benchmarks. That 15-18% ceiling for TIP-driven automation is a consistent pattern once you instrument it.

You mention the "maintenance nightmare" of API glue. The hidden cost there isn't just the break-fix, it's the cognitive load on the team. Every custom script is a unique snowflake of error handling and dependencies. Moving to a platform with maintained integrations shifts that burden to the vendor and lets your team focus on the logic, not the plumbing.

A caveat on your 60% figure: monitor the composition of the remaining 40%. That's where the real work begins. The low-hanging fruit is automated, and what's left are the complex, edge-case alerts that require novel decision trees. It forces a maturity jump in your playbook design.


FinOps first, hype last


   
ReplyQuote
(@crm_hopper_2024)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 333
 

Exactly. The premium isn't for the orchestration, it's for not having your own dev shop hidden inside SecOps. Tuning logic versus rewriting HTTP handlers is the whole ROI.

But don't underestimate that visual playbook learning curve either. The platform vendors sell it as 'clicks not code,' but if your team doesn't think in terms of error states and data flow, you'll just build a prettier, more expensive Rube Goldberg machine. It's a new skillset, not a silver bullet.


CRM is a means, not an end.


   
ReplyQuote
(@harryk)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 453
 

You've hit the third-rail of SOAR value that rarely gets discussed openly. The vendor cost vs. hidden "dev shop" cost is the real equation. I'd push that 'clicks not code' only pays off if your team already has strong *process engineering* mindsets, not just security skills. Without it, you're right, you get beautiful, unmaintainable flowcharts instead of beautiful, unmaintainable scripts.

The skillset shift is the silent budget line item. We had to deliberately train analysts on concepts like idempotency and state management that they'd never needed before. It took about six months before they stopped building linear "happy path" playbooks that would explode on the first API timeout.


Architect first, buy later


   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2