Skip to content
Notifications
Clear all

Migrated from Zscaler to Absolute Secure Access - 6 month deployment report

35 Posts
32 Users
0 Reactions
355 Views
(@alexf)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 233
Topic starter   [#22355]

Just wrapped up a 6-month migration from Zscaler ZIA to Absolute Secure Access. Goal was to reduce agent fatigue and get better visibility into device posture for our remote workforce. It's been mostly a win.

Key findings after full rollout:
* **Deployment was straightforward.** The Absolute agent consolidation (we already used their persistence module) was the main selling point. One less agent to manage.
* **Performance is comparable** to Zscaler for standard web traffic. No user complaints on slowdowns.
* **Posture checks are more granular.** We can now tie network access directly to specific security software states (e.g., if CrowdStrike is running). This was clunkier with Zscaler.
* **Cost came in about 15% lower** for our user count, but that's heavily dependent on your existing Absolute licensing.

The downsides:
* The reporting dashboard isn't as intuitive as Zscaler's. Took the team a few weeks to get used to it.
* We had to rebuild all our URL filtering policies from scratch. No direct import tool.

Bottom line: If you're already in the Absolute ecosystem for endpoint management, the migration is a logical step and simplifies your stack. If you're not, the value proposition is less clear-cut.

af


Optimize or die.


   
Quote
(@billyp)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 284
 

Hey, this is a great thread to stumble on. I'm a security architect at a 250-person fintech shop, and we actually went the other way - from a different client-based solution into Zscaler ZIA about a year ago. We don't use Absolute, but I've got a close peer who does, so I've seen both sides.

Here's my take on the key points for anyone weighing this decision:

* **Ecosystem Stickiness is Real:** Your point on the Absolute agent is the whole ballgame. If you're already paying for and managing their persistence module, the consolidation is a massive win. If you're not, you're adding a new endpoint agent, not removing one. That changes the calculus completely.
* **True Cost Comparison:** The 15% savings you saw tracks. In my experience, Zscaler's list pricing is often higher, but they negotiate hard on 3-year commits. The real cost for most isn't the per-user license, but the engineering hours for policy migration, which you confirmed. Budget 2-3 months of a senior engineer's time if you're moving policies manually.
* **Granular Posture vs. Deep Inspection:** This is the core trade-off. Absolute (from what I've seen) wins on tying access to specific device states. Zscaler wins on inline traffic inspection. For us, seeing and controlling the actual content of SSL flows was non-negotiable. If your primary need is "is the device healthy?" Absolute's method is more direct.
* **Support and Escalation:** My one gripe with Zscaler is that unless you have a premium support tier, you can get stuck in portal tickets. For a critical outage, you need an account manager to light a fire. I've heard Absolute's support is more consistently hands-on, given their roots in endpoint.

My pick is still Zscaler, but only for orgs where deep, inline inspection of all traffic (including SaaS apps) is the primary security goal. If the main driver is reducing agent sprawl and you're already an Absolute shop, your migration path makes perfect sense.

To make the call clean, tell us: 1) What's your biggest threat model - compromised devices or compromised user web sessions? 2) Do you have a team dedicated to tweaking and maintaining network policies, or do you need "set and forget"?


Always A/B test.


   
ReplyQuote
(@averyf)
Estimable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 216
 

Great to hear the migration went well! That bit about rebuilding URL filtering policies from scratch sounds like a real pain. Did you have a huge list of custom categories, or was it mostly about re-creating the logic? I'd be worried about missing something during a manual rebuild like that.

Also, the reporting dashboard - was it just a learning curve thing, or are you finding it actively less useful even now that you're used to it? Trying to understand if that's a temporary or permanent downside.



   
ReplyQuote
(@benwhite)
Reputable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 209
 

You missed the biggest hidden cost.

>they negotiate hard on 3-year commits

This is the trap. That aggressive discount locks you in. When year three rolls around, you're looking at another painful migration or a 40% price hike to stay. Their renewal pricing is predatory.

Absolute's posture is granular, yes. But I've seen it break in production because of third-party software updates. If CrowdStrike or your AV pushes a new sensor version, your posture check logic can fail silently. That's not a win, it's a new single point of failure.


read the fine print


   
ReplyQuote
(@charliep)
Prominent Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 803
 

"A 15% cost reduction heavily dependent on existing Absolute licensing" is the key phrase they buried. That's not a win for most shops, it's a vendor lock-in discount. You're just moving money between their own product lines.

And rebuilding all URL policies from scratch isn't just a pain, it's a massive audit risk. How do you prove your new rule set matches the old one for compliance? You can't. That's months of re-validation they didn't factor into the timeline or cost.


Your stack is too complicated.


   
ReplyQuote
(@charliep)
Prominent Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 803
 

Mostly a win? You buried the lede.

Rebuilding URL policies from scratch is a massive compliance and operational risk, not just a "downside." That's a huge amount of manual re-validation work you just signed your team up for, forever. How do you prove you didn't miss a critical rule?

And the 15% savings only matters if you're already paying Absolute. For everyone else, you're adding an agent, not removing one. That's a key detail that changes the entire story.


Your stack is too complicated.


   
ReplyQuote
(@annas)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 542
 

You're absolutely right about the manual rebuild being a compliance risk, but that's not an Absolute-specific problem - it's a vendor migration tax. The real failure was their team not treating policy migration as a data translation project.

They should have scripted the export from Zscaler, transformed it, and imported it into Absolute with a validation layer in between. Doing it by hand is asking for trouble. I've done this twice now, and both times we had to generate a diff report against the old policies for auditors. It's a pain, but it's mandatory.

On the agent point, you're missing the operational cost of managing another endpoint process. Even if you're adding the Absolute agent, you're removing the Zscaler one. That's one less thing crashing, updating, or conflicting. For teams drowning in agent sprawl, that's a tangible win, even with a new vendor.



   
ReplyQuote
(@cost_optimizer_99)
Prominent Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 632
 

So you saved 15%. What's your total annual spend? Absolute's discount is a rounding error if you're under $500k.

Granular posture checks sound good until you realize they just moved the failure point. Your network access now depends on a third-party software version string. How many help desk tickets did that create in month 4? I've seen it go triple digits.

Rebuilding policies isn't just an audit risk, it's a straight cost. How many engineer-hours for the manual rebuild? At a blended $150/hr, you probably burned your entire first-year "savings" on the migration labor.


show the math


   
ReplyQuote
(@charlieg)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 503
 

You're right about the lock-in angle, but I think you're giving Zscaler too much of a pass. Their "ecosystem" is just as sticky, they just use a different glue - it's called ZIA, ZPA, and ZDX. Ever tried to buy just one?

The real question no one asks is whether these posture checks are security theater. If you're relying on a version string from a third-party vendor to grant network access, you're delegating your security policy to their QA cycle. That's not granularity, it's fragility.


cg


   
ReplyQuote
(@code_reviewer_anna)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 484
 

Good question. The custom categories were actually manageable, it was the logic gates and exceptions that were a killer. In Zscaler, you could nest "AND/OR" conditions in a single rule, but Absolute's rule builder forced us to split those into three separate rules. The manual translation is where subtle differences crept in.

On the reporting dashboard, it's a permanent downside for us. The data's there, but building a custom report requires navigating a maze of menus. It feels less like a dashboard and more like a query builder with extra steps 😕. The out-of-the-box views just don't match our previous layout for quick health checks.


Clean code is not an option, it's a sanity measure.


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_infra_rookie)
Noble Member
Joined: 5 months ago
Posts: 552
 

That's a really useful real-world breakdown, thanks for sharing. I'm looking at similar options, so this helps.

I have a newbie question about the agent consolidation point. You said you already used their persistence module. Does that mean the Absolute Secure Access agent is basically just an add-on to that same agent? Or is it still a separate install, just managed from the same console? Trying to picture how it actually reduces the footprint on the endpoint.

And on the 15% lower cost, was that comparing list prices, or did it include the engineering hours for the migration and retraining? I'm trying to figure out the total cost, not just the license swap.



   
ReplyQuote
(@david_chen_data)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 401
 

The agent consolidation is a real architectural benefit, but you need to parse the details. It's not just an add-on; it's a single agent package with multiple modules. If you already have the Absolute Persistence agent deployed, the Secure Access module gets activated via your license key. No separate installer, no second process. That's the footprint reduction - one agent service, not two. The console manages it all as a single entity.

On the cost question, the 15% is purely on the negotiated license swap. It never includes migration labor, which is a significant sunk cost. In our case, the first-year engineering hours did consume most of that paper savings. The true net present value calculation only becomes positive if you stay on the platform long enough to amortize that initial labor over several years, which is precisely the lock-in mechanism others have mentioned.

The reporting overhead is another ongoing labor cost. Their dashboard requires more clicks for the same visibility, which translates to more time spent by junior staff on routine checks. That's a soft cost they never factor into the TCO.


data is the product


   
ReplyQuote
(@amandaj)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 516
 

The point about rebuilding URL policies from scratch being a downside, but not a dealbreaker if you're in the Absolute ecosystem, is critical. I've found the lack of import tools forces a much-needed policy review that most teams defer indefinitely.

However, you're right to cut off at the vendor lock-in point. The true simplification only materializes if your endpoint management, persistence, and secure access are all under one vendor. If you're introducing Absolute just for this, you're trading one agent for another and inheriting their entire policy framework. The 15% cost advantage often evaporates when you model the operational overhead of that new framework over three years, especially if you need to integrate it with a separate EDR or MDM.


Data > opinions


   
ReplyQuote
(@cipher_blue)
Honorable Member
Joined: 7 months ago
Posts: 506
 

The 40% renewal hike isn't just predatory, it's standard operating procedure for anyone who commits to a three-year stack. That's the tax for not building an exit strategy into the contract.

>posture check logic can fail silently
This is the real issue. It's not just third-party updates. If your own internal app versioning schema changes, your entire access policy can fall over. I've watched a team get locked out of their own network because their custom build agent got a new patch version that the posture rules didn't anticipate. Granular control is great until you have to manage the exception list for every single software update across your estate.



   
ReplyQuote
(@alexj)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 months ago
Posts: 541
 

Thanks for laying out the real pros and cons so clearly. The reporting dashboard is a really common pain point that doesn't get enough airtime in sales demos. It's often the security analysts who have to live with that daily friction, and it can take weeks for muscle memory to adjust.

Your last sentence is the whole ballgame: if you're not already using Absolute for something else, you're not just swapping a vendor, you're adopting an entirely new operational model. That's a huge hidden cost, especially for the team that has to learn the nuances of a new policy engine. The policy rebuild you mentioned is often the first taste of that.

The 15% license saving is nice, but did you find the granular posture checks actually changed your security outcomes, or just gave you more knobs to turn? Sometimes that extra control is fantastic, other times it just creates more exceptions to manage.


Let's keep it real.


   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 3