Unpopular opinion: CircleCI's UI is better than GitHub Actions, but the pricing is a joke

gracem · 2026-09-26T05:16:01Z

Alright, I'm ready for the hot takes and the "well, actually..." replies 😅. But after setting up pipelines for a dozen SaaS clients this quarter, I've solidified this view. For context, I'm mostly automating for small-to-mid dev teams (3-10 people) with monorepos or a handful of connected services. Here's my breakdown: **Where CircleCI's UI wins (for me):** * The "Insights" tab is fantastic for spotting flaky tests and pipeline bottlenecks. GitHub's analytics feel like an afterthought. * Visual pipeline configuration (the "Visual Editor") is a godssend for onboarding junior devs or quickly sketching out a flow. It just makes the DAG of jobs so much clearer. * Debugging via SSH into a job is smoother. The workflow visualization feels more responsive when you're hunting for where something failed. **The pricing punchline:** CircleCI's new pricing model (credits) murdered my budget for a side project. A medium Docker-based build (~15 minutes) can chew through 5,000+ credits. Compared to GitHub Actions, where the same team gets **3,000-10,000 *free* minutes per month** (depending on OS) on their existing plan... it's not even close. My benchmark? For a team of 5 with a Node.js monorepo and Docker builds: * **GitHub Actions:** ~$0/month (stayed within free tier) * **CircleCI:** Ballparked at ~$180/month on the "Performance" plan for similar concurrency and speed. The verdict? I *want* to use CircleCI for its polish and UX. But I can't justify the cost when GitHub Actions is "good enough" and practically free for many small teams. It feels like CircleCI is pricing for enterprise now and leaving the enthusiasts & startups behind. Anyone else making this tough choice? Found a clever way to make CircleCI's pricing work for a small team?

Page 3 / 3 Prev

CI/CD Tool Comparisons

Last Post by helenr 6 days ago

31 Posts

29 Users

0 Reactions

16 Views

RSS

helenr

(@helenr)

Honorable Member

Joined: 3 months ago

Posts: 534

27/09/2026 3:53 am

You can find the OS breakdown under your organization's settings, in the "Billing & plans" section. The usage report there shows consumption by runner operating system.

I agree it's rough if you need Windows. A practical workaround some teams use is to keep CI on Linux runners for the bulk of the work, then only spin up a Windows runner for the final validation steps. It's not perfect, but it helps stretch those free minutes.

And yes, this all means the headline "3,000 free minutes" is a bit misleading if you don't read the fine print.

—HR

ReplyQuote

Page 3 / 3 Prev