Hey everyone. I made the switch from Helicone to Freeplay a couple weeks ago to try out their more advanced eval features. I'm still getting my head around a lot of this, so apologies if this is a basic question.
In Helicone, I could easily see cost per user or per session in the dashboard. With Freeplay, I'm only seeing overall project costs and costs broken down by model. I can't figure out how to map costs back to individual users for our billing. Has anyone else run into this? Is there a setting I'm missing, or do I need to tag things differently? Thanks for any pointers.
I'm a marketing analytics lead for a mid-sized B2C SaaS. Our team uses both platforms in different contexts - Helicone for monitoring our customer-facing GPT feature, and Freeplay for internal LLM experimentation and evaluation. Here's how they've shaken out for us.
* **Core User Model:** Helicone treats every request as part of a user session by default, tagging costs to a user ID automatically. Freeplay is built around the concept of "conversations" and "evaluations," so costs are primarily aggregated by model or project. User-level costing requires explicit tagging at the API call level, which is a manual setup.
* **Pricing & Visibility:** Helicone's pricing is per-request, around $10 per million tokens processed at our scale. Freeplay's model is project-based, starting around $500/month. The key difference is that Helicone's per-user costs are a dashboard view, while with Freeplay, you must create a custom report using their tagging system, which adds a layer of work.
* **Integration & Setup:** Helicone's proxy was a drop-in replacement for our OpenAI calls, taking an afternoon. Freeplay required more deliberate instrumentation - defining templates, labeling conversations, and setting up evaluations - which took a few days of engineering time to get meaningful data.
* **Where Each Wins:** Helicone wins on real-time, granular cost monitoring and per-user attribution right out of the box. Freeplay's strength is the deep eval workflow: running batch tests, comparing model outputs, and tracking performance metrics across different prompt versions, which Helicone doesn't focus on.
Given your focus on user-level costs for billing, I'd recommend sticking with Helicone unless you're heavily using the eval features. If you need both, tell us 1) whether you have engineering resources to implement and maintain the tagging Freeplay requires, and 2) how critical A/B testing prompt templates is to your workflow.
Measure twice, spend once
That's a good breakdown of their operational models. Your point about Freeplay requiring *manual tagging at the API call level* for user-level costing is spot on, and it's the core architectural difference.
We ran into the same thing. The workaround is to embed a user or account ID in every request using Freeplay's custom metadata fields. It adds overhead to your integration, but once it's done, you can slice the billing data by that tag in their analytics. It's just not the out-of-the-box view Helicone provides.
One caveat on the pricing side: while Freeplay's project-based fee is fixed, you still pay the underlying model costs (OpenAI, Anthropic, etc.) on top. So that $500 is really an analytics/eval platform fee, not the total LLM spend.
Every dollar counts.
And you're still trusting the data after that manual tagging setup? That's the real kicker. I've seen teams mess up the metadata injection, get inconsistent tagging, and then spend days reconciling their numbers. So you pay the platform fee, add the integration overhead, and the data quality is still on you.
It's not a workaround, it's a trap. You traded one problem for three.
If it ain't broke, don't 'upgrade' it.
You're right about the underlying model costs, but the visibility issue runs deeper. The $500 project fee is just the start. You have to audit the pass-through costs from Azure OpenAI or AWS Bedrock, which often have complex tiered pricing and data transfer fees not reflected in Freeplay's simplified model breakdown.
That custom metadata field becomes a critical cost allocation key. If it's missing from even 5% of requests due to an edge case, your per-user cost analysis is functionally useless for any serious financial reporting. You end up building a secondary reconciliation layer anyway, which negates much of the platform's value.
The real comparison isn't just Helicone's per-token fee versus Freeplay's project fee. It's the total cost of ownership for accurate cost attribution, which includes engineering time for tagging, data validation, and reconciliation overhead.
Always check the data transfer costs.
No setting missing. That's just how Freeplay works. It's built for eval loops, not customer billing.
You tag it yourself or you don't get the data. As others have pointed out, that's a fast track to inconsistent reporting and a world of reconciliation pain.
If user-level cost allocation is a hard requirement, you probably picked the wrong tool for that job. The eval features are nice, but they won't fix your billing spreadsheet.
Prove it.
Yep, that's the trade-off for the eval features. You need to pass a `user_id` (or similar) in the custom metadata with every single call. If you're using their SDK, it's often just an extra field you set.
The trick is getting that metadata injected consistently across all your endpoints and workflows. Miss one integration path and your user-level costs get skewed. It adds a maintenance layer you didn't have with Helicone.
Webhooks or bust.
You're hitting the core difference between the tools. Freeplay's model is conversations and evals, not per-user cost tracking.
You need to embed a custom metadata field like `external_user_id` in every request, either via their SDK or API headers. If you skip that step anywhere, those costs vanish into the project total and your billing data is garbage.
What nobody mentions is that even if you tag everything perfectly, Freeplay's analytics dashboard still doesn't give you a clean "cost per user" view out of the box. You have to export the data and build that report yourself. So you're paying for a platform and then doing the work anyway.
garbage in, garbage out
Exactly right. I took that same path trying to get the best of both worlds and ended up building a separate reconciliation pipeline anyway. The eval features are compelling, but they don't offset the manual overhead for operational cost tracking.
You really feel the pain when a bug in your tagging logic silently misattributes costs for a week, and you only catch it during the monthly billing run. That's when you realize you've traded a simple per-token fee for a hidden engineering tax.
Data doesn't lie, but dashboards sometimes do.
Absolutely, and welcome to the big Freeplay learning curve. You're not missing a setting - that visibility gap is by design, and it's the first thing most of us trip over coming from a tool like Helicone.
The short answer is you need to manually pass a `user_id` in the custom metadata with *every single request* via their SDK or headers. But the real catch, which I learned the hard way, is that this creates a silent data dependency across your entire codebase. If a new developer adds a new API route without that metadata tag, those user costs just disappear into the project total, and you won't notice until your billing reconciliation fails. It shifts the burden of accuracy from the platform to your team's discipline.
The eval features are fantastic, but they come with this hidden operational tax. You might find yourself building a separate audit log just to verify your tags, which feels like rebuilding the dashboard you already paid for.
Measure twice, automate once.
That silent data dependency you describe is the perfect summary of the architectural risk. It forces you to treat every new API endpoint or client library update as a potential cost attribution failure.
We mitigated it by implementing a middleware layer that automatically injects the user context from our auth token into Freeplay's metadata, which helps. But then you're just shifting the dependency to the middleware's reliability and coverage. We still run a nightly reconciliation job against our own application logs to catch any tagged requests the middleware might have missed, which feels redundant.
The real cost isn't the $500 platform fee, it's the engineering hours spent building and maintaining these safety nets.
- Mike
You're not missing a setting. That's the architectural trade-off.
Freeplay's value is in evals, not cost attribution. To get user-level data, you must consistently pass a custom metadata field like `external_user_id` with every single request, which becomes a brittle data dependency across your entire codebase.
Missing it in one endpoint skews your billing data and you won't know until reconciliation fails. You're paying for a platform, then building the reporting yourself.
Show me the bill
That "brittle data dependency" point is exactly what worries me. How do you even test you've covered every endpoint? Do you have to audit your code after every deploy?
Yeah, that's the welcome gift with Freeplay. You trade one dashboard for a manual tagging operation that becomes a single point of failure for your billing.
>Is there a setting I'm missing?
Nope. That's the product. Their advanced eval features require you to build the cost tracking yourself. You need to embed a `user_id` in custom metadata on every single API call, and even then, you won't get a native "cost per user" view. You export the data and build the report in a spreadsheet.
The real question isn't about a missing setting. It's whether you want your billing accuracy to depend on every developer remembering to add a metadata tag for the next five years.
Trust but verify.
You've correctly identified the fundamental pivot Freeplay requires. Everyone hits this exact wall. The setting you're looking for doesn't exist.
Freeplay's data model is built around conversations and evaluations, not cost attribution. To get even close to user-level costs, you must inject a custom metadata field (e.g., `external_user_id`) on every single API request, without exception. This creates a pervasive and often undocumented dependency in your codebase.
You will still have to export the raw data and build the "cost per user" report yourself, as their dashboard doesn't surface it. So you're trading Helicone's built-in visibility for a manual reporting pipeline you now own.
Show me the numbers, not the roadmap.